Aug
29
2009
0

Top 10 Articles on This Mighty Scourge – June to August 2009

I know I have many new readers on This Mighty Scourge -the Civil War blog.  Currently This Mighty Scourge is reaching 5,000–6,000 unique readers per month.  I assume many of you have found out about my blog through Facebook advertising and some may have found out because you are part of my Facebook Group, “American Civil War Battlefields.”  I am sure others have found my blog through search engines such as Google, Bing and Yahoo.  Regardless of how you have found me – thank you for taking time to read my blog.

I thought it might be helpful, for new and veteran readers alike, to give a listing of my top ten articles for the last three months.  I have left out updates on the Wilderness Wal-Mart as they are news stories and pick up huge amounts of readers.  I have included author interviews, battle narratives, soldier biographies and regimental/brigade histories.  These are articles and essays that I’ve written.  Please take time to read the articles you have not read.  Also, please leave comments about my blog articles.  Make sure to leave these on my blog, so they can be read by all of my readers.  Remember, we love to hear from you.  You will have to register for a free WordPress account to leave comments.  I have included instructions on my blog.

This Mighty Scourge – Top 10 Articles (June-August 2009)

10.  Test Drive: The Complete Gettysburg Guide by J. David Petruzzi

9.   Second Manassas – Again the Fields Turned Red

8.  Wilson’s Creek – the Civil War breaks out in the West

7.  Interview with Scott L. Mingus, Sr. – author of Flames Beyond Gettysburg

6.  The Battle of the Crater

5.  The Fighting 69th New York Infantry Regiment and the Irish Brigade

4.  Interview with James A. Hessler, author of Sickles at Gettysburg

3.  Interview with J. David Petruzzi Author of The Complete Gettysburg Guide

2.  Interview with Earl J. Hess, Author of In The Trenches of Petersburg

And for the most popular article over the past 90 days…..

1.  Interview with Jim Lighthizer, President of the Civil War Preservation Trust

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Aug
28
2009
2

Second Manassas – Again the Fields Turned Red

Federal Cannon on Chinn RidgeToday marks the 147th anniversary of the start of the Battle of Second Manassas.  For three days in August 1862, death revisited the fields north of Manassas Junction, Virginia.  Barely a year after US Brigadier General Irvin McDowell was turned away, by CSA Brigadier General P.G.T. Beauregard, at the First Battle of Manassas, an even deadlier affair would be fought on the same rolling hills.

This time the Federal troops were commanded by US Major General John Pope.  Designated the Army of Virginia, they were opposed by CSA General Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia.  Pope, strong willed and bombastic, was reeling from his bloody repulse at the Battle of Cedar Mountain on August 9, 1862.  With his army widely scattered, he was John Popesearching for CSA Major General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson’s Left Wing.  According to intelligence Pope received, Jackson was bivouacked at Centreville, Virginia – approximately five miles east of the plains of the First Manassas Battlefield.  Late in the afternoon, on August 28, portions of US Major General Irvin McDowell’s III Corps were attacked as the pushed east on the Warrenton Turnpike, near Groveton, Virginia.  Still west of the Manassas battlefield, US Brigadier General John Gibbon’s brigade was surprised by the volley of artillery slamming into their left flank – from the north.  Believing the fire was coming from Confederate horse artillery, Gibbon deployed his brigade and advanced north towards Brawner’s Farm, unaware that he was opposed by an entire division of Jackson’s detachment.  The fighting quickly escalated with Gibbon being reinforced by US Brigadier General Abner Doubleday’s brigade.  The Battle of Brawner’s Farm was extremely brutal, with some of the most desperate fighting of the war occurring while the Federal army was spread out and very vulnerable.  Brawner’s Farm, while considered a separate battle, was the prelude to one of the largest battles of the Civil War – Second Manassas.

Get comfortable, and relax.  Take a journey with me to August 1862, to the fields north of Manassas Junction where one of the bloodiest battles of the American Civil War took place.  The following essay comes from my other website, BattlefieldPortraits.com.  Enjoy.

Battle of Second Manassas
(also known as 2nd Bull Run)


Location: Manassas, VA
Dates: August 28 – 30, 1862
Union Commander:  John Pope, Major General
Confederate Commander:  Robert E. Lee, General

Battle Summary:
Robert E. Lee had accomplished the unimaginable.  He had pushed US Major General George B. McClellan’s massive Army of the Potomac, from the “Gates of Richmond.”  After CSA General Joseph Johnston was wounded, at the battle of Seven Pines, Robert Lee would take over command of the Army of Northern Virginia.  During the Seven Days battles, Lee would hammer McClellan’s larger army until it was pushed to Harrison’s Landing, on the James River.

In the west, after earning a victory at Island #10, US Major General John Pope would be brought east, by Abraham Lincoln.  Creating the Army of Virginia, Lincoln determined to pressure Robert E. Lee, from northern Virginia.  Lee would detach his 2d Corps, commanded by CSA Major General Thomas Jackson, to keep Pope from reinforcing McClellan.  This would culminate in the Battle of Cedar Mountain, where US Major General Nathanial Bank’s detachment, from the Army of Virginia, would be badly trounced by Jackson.

Pope would consolidate his army, north of the Rappahannock River, and await Jackson’s next move.  In the meantime, with George McClellan’s Army of the Potomac retreating from the peninsula, Robert E. Lee quickly moved to consolidate his army, and deal with John Pope.

For several days, in late August, after the consolidation of the Army of Northern Virginia, John Pope did not know where Lee’s army was.  Still camped near Culpeper, Virginia, Pope would learn quickly about the speed Thomas Jackson’s “foot cavalry.”  Having “forced marched” his 2d Corps northwest, through Thoroughfare Gap, Jackson attacked Pope’s supply line, at Bristoe Station.  Pope would not learn of this until a train, destined for Bristoe Station, would rapidly return to Pope describing the terrible destruction of his supply line.

This news broke John Pope’s lethargy.  He quickly put his Army of Virginia into motion, in an effort to defeat Jackson’s lone 2d Corps.  Using separate roads, Pope’s army quickly pushed north.  US Major General Franz Sigel’s I Corps, and Irvin McDowell’s III Corps, represented the left army Franz Sigel - Second Manassaswing.  Nathanial Bank’s II Corps would push north on the army’s right flank.  Additionally, US Major Generals Joseph Hooker and Jesse Reno’s divisions, from the Army of the Potomac, would be in the army’s right wing.

As McDowell’s III Corps pushed north, US Brigadier General James Ricketts would detach his division, from McDowell, and push west.  Ricketts’ concern with protecting the Army of Virginia’s left flank, would culminate in a short, but brutal battle, at Thoroughfare Gap, against CS Major General James Longstreet’s 1st Corps division, commanded by CS Brigadier General Cadmus Wilcox.  Facing the entire 1st Corps, of Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia, Ricketts’ division did not stand a chance.  Once he was pushed aside, Robert E. Lee could consolidate his army to fight Pope.  Speed was essential as Lee recognized that Pope could defeat his two wings piecemeal.

Certain that he would find Jackson at Centreville, Virginia, John Pope pushed his army towards the familiar fields near the Bull Run Creek.  Late on August 28, approaching from the west along the Warrenton Turnpike, Irvin McDowell’s III Corps would find Thomas Jackson’s 2d Corps.  Marching east were US Brigadier General John Reynolds’ division of Pennsylvanians, followed by US Brigadier General Rufus King’s division.  Just west of the old battlefield, near Pageland Avenue, Union troops spotted what appeared to be Confederate cavalry, north of the turnpike, scouting their movements.  Brawner Farm LaneSoon thereafter, the Rebels disappeared and King’s division started to receive cannon fire from the same ridge.  The battle of Second Manassas had opened.  In what would later been known as the Battle of Brawner’s Farm, US Brigadier Generals John Gibbon, and Abner Doubleday, would engage the entire right flank of Jackson’s 2nd Corps.  These Federal brigades would hold Jackson to a draw, during a battle that would last long past sunset.  Gibbon’s all western brigade, then called the “Black Hat Brigade” (they wore black hats similar to the regular army) would start earning the reputation that would lead to their designation - after the battle of South Mountain – the Iron Brigade.  Absent from the field near Brawner’s Farm was division commander Rufus King, who suffered a seizure, corps commander, Irvin McDowell and army commander, John Pope.  Gibbon, and Doubleday, would fight this battle without any senior command structure.  The Confederacy would temporarily suffer a significant loss when CS Major General Richard Ewell would sustain an injury to his leg, that would require amputation.

When notified of the evening’s fighting, Pope and McDowell were sure that King’s division had fought a detachment of cavalry - and perhaps a small amount of infantry.  They were positive that Jackson’s Corps was in Centreville.  Overnight they would bivouac east of Sudley Road, near the Stone House, and move on Jackson the next day.  What they did not know Franz Sigel's Position on August 29was that Jackson’s entire Corps was hidden in an abandoned railroad cut, just west of their position.  From there, Jackson would fight much of Sigel’s I Corps, on August 29.  In what would be piecemeal attacks, Sigel would engage Jackson.  After the battle, Jackson would be criticized for not launching a larger attack against Sigel – perhaps collapsing Pope’s right flank, and quickly destroying his scattered Army of Virginia.  The day’s fighting would end with the two armies in essentially the same position as they started in – with the exception that Robert E. Lee had arrived with the rest of his army.  James Longstreet’s 1st Corps was positioned north to south along Chinn Ridge, south of the Warrenton Turnpike.  Late in the afternoon, CSA Brigadier General John Bell Hood would attack John Reynolds’ division, along Chinn Ridge.  Pope was still not convinced that he faced the entire Army of Northern Virginia – he would find out otherwise, the next day.

On August 30, John Pope would send a large force, nearly 10,000 men, against what he now believed was just Jackson’s 2d Corps.  Attacking north of the Warrenton Turnpike, against the railroad cut, Pope would experience some success.  Robert E. Lee, seeing his opportunity to crush John Pope, wheeled James Longstreet’s 1st Corps on its left flank, and like a giant scissors slammed into John Pope’s left flank – a direction Pope was warned to expect attack - but refused to believe a threat existed.  Pope’s entire army, including US Major General Fitz John Porter’s recently arrived V Corps, from the Army of the Potomac, were sent reeling.  The unexpected attack would rout Pope’s Army of Virginia, resulting in another retreat back to Washington DC along the Warrenton Turnpike – the same route that Irvin McDowell’s army took when defeated at First Manassas.

Additional Resources:

Mike’s Photographic Essay on Second Manassas
Second Manassas Battlefield Maps from the Civil War Preservation Trust

Campaign: Second Manassas

Outcome: Confederate Victory

Troop Strengths
Union: 63,000
Confederate: 55,000

Casualties (estimated):
Union: 13,826 (killed, wounded or missing/captured)
Confederate: 8,353 (killed, wounded or missing/captured)

Battle Aftermath:
With John Pope’s retreat back to Washington City, the Army of Virginia was badly dispirited and disorganized.  This army would be combined with the Army of the Potomac.  Lincoln, once again, would turn to George McClellan to straighten out the army tasked with protecting the nation’s capitol.

Robert E. Lee, in an effort to recruit new troops and move the fighting out of Virginia, would invade Maryland.  McClellan would chase Lee, fighting him at South Mountain on September 14.  On September 17, the two huge armies would again clash, this time near Sharpsburg, Maryland along Antietam Creek.  The fighting at Antietam would be brutal, providing the country its single bloodiest day of battle – a record that still survives today.  Lee would barely escape Antietam.  His primary goal of recruiting soldiers was a failure.  While modern historians consider the Battle of Antietam a draw, Lincoln used the quasi-victory as an occasion to issue his Emancipation Proclamation, altering the war’s objective from reunion of the states to reunion with slavery abolished.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 4.8/5 (12 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +9 (from 9 votes)

Aug
26
2009
0

Wilderness Wal-Mart Opponents Speak Out

As reported on the Civil War Preservation Trust’s website today, opponents of the Wilderness Wal-Mart are vowing not to concede defeat.  On Monday, August 24, the Orange County Board of Supervisors voted 4-1  to grant a special use permit to Wal-Mart.  This special use permit would allow Wal-Mart to build a new Supercenter within 1/4 mile of The Wilderness battlefield – all within easy sight lines of one of the most hallowed Civil War battlefields in Virginia.  This was Wal-Mart’s last hurdle to building their new location.

Civil War Preservation Trust president, Jim Lighthizer, was quoted as saying, “The ball is now in Wal-Mart’s court.  Wal-Mart better understands the nationwide anger generated by its proposal to build on the doorstep of a National Park.  It is in the corporation’s best interests to work with the preservation community to find an alternative site.  We are optimistic that company officials will see the wisdom of moving elsewhere.”  Coalition leaders asked if legal action is now likely, declined to comment.

For more information on the most recent news, check out the following two articles.

For the Fredericksburg.com article click HERE.
For the Washington Post article click HERE.

Please consider becoming a member of the Civil War Preservation Trust by clicking HERE.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (10 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +7 (from 7 votes)

Aug
25
2009
0

Wilderness Wal-Mart Update

At 12:50 a.m., this morning, the Orange County Board of Supervisors voted 4-1 in favor of granting Wal-Mart a special use permit.  This permit will allow them to build a Wal-Mart Supercenter adjacent to The Wilderness Battlefield.  Historians have proven that the Supercenter’s location will be on the actual battlefield, but not within the Fredericksburg Spotsylvania National Military Park’s boundaries.  I for one, am concerned that a proud American company, like Wal-Mart, would desecrate the sacred ground of The Wilderness – all in an effort to increase sales.  I know many Civil War buffs, including myself, who will think twice about supporting Wal-Mart by purchasing their products.

Watch for more news as it becomes available.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (28 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +16 (from 16 votes)

Aug
21
2009
0

Breaking News on the Wilderness Wal-Mart

Stop the Wilderness Wal-MartI received an email from Jim Campi, of the CWPT, this afternoon.  The text of the letter is below.  The short version is that the Orange County Planning Commission voted 4–4 against recommending approval of the of Wal-Mart’s special use permit.  As it is not a majority in favor of the special use permit, it is the same as a “NO.”

Get involved!

Mike Noirot

 

*****************************************

August 21, 2009 – 4:30 PM EST

Planning Commission Recommends Against Special Use Permit, But Threat to Battlefield Remains

Last night, the Orange County Planning Commission voted 4-4 against recommending approval of Walmart’s special use permit at its rescheduled public hearing. Although a tie, the vote is functionally the same as a denial, since it was not approved by a majority of the commissioners.  The vote is a reversal of what occurred in July, when the commission prematurely approved the application 5-4.

It is now more critical than ever for supporters of the Wilderness and historic preservation to attend Monday’s Board of Supervisors hearing, as it is important to remember that the Planning Commission is a non-binding advisory organization. The Board of Supervisors has final authority in this matter and Monday’s hearing represents the last opportunity to tell them that the Wilderness Battlefield is no place for big box sprawl. If you live within driving distance, please attend this final hearing and urge the county to find another location further from this hallowed battleground.

The hearing starts at 6:00 p.m. on Monday, August 24, 2009, in the Orange County High School Auditorium, 201 Selma Road, Orange, Va.  CWPT will have an information table set-up one hour before the hearing, and we encourage all who attend to arrive early. Click here for directions and a map of the school.

I hope we can count on your continued support in this fight to protect the Wilderness Battlefield. If you have any questions about the upcoming hearing please feel free to contact me personally at 202-367-1861 ext. 7205.

Thank you,
Jim Campi

P.S.  For the latest information on the hearings, please visit CWPT’s Wilderness Walmart homepage.

 
www.civilwar.org

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (3 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +3 (from 3 votes)

Aug
20
2009
2

The Fighting 69th New York Infantry Regiment and the Irish Brigade

This past week I have been immersed in reading Bradley M. Gottfried’s newest book, “The Maps of First Bull Run.”  While not a full narrative of the battle, it is nearly so.  While reading about the battle, Mr. Gottfried detailed some of the actions of the 69th New York Militia – later to be the 69th New York Infantry.  Always one of my favorite regiments, it was consolidated into US Brigadier General Thomas F. Meagher’s famed Irish Brigade.  Reading about them got me excited about writing a history on the 69th and its contributions to the Civil War.  I hope you enjoy my article.  Please watch for an in depth review of Mr. Gottfried’s new book in the coming weeks.

Irish Brigade Regimental FlagThe 69th New York Infantry had a proud heritage.  Originally designated the Irish Rifles Company, it would be the original unit of the 69th New York Militia.  After coming to the United States in 1849, Michael Corcoran would become involved in the Irish Rifles.  Well connected politically, Corcoran would advance within the ranks of the Rifles, prior to the Civil War, and would become involved in political dealings with the Democrats of Tammany Hall.  With the outbreak of sectional hostilities, he became active in recruiting a regiment – the 69th New York Militia.  Meanwhile, Thomas Francis Meagher was deciding where his loyalties should be directed.  On one hand, he was sympathetic to the Southern cause, believing it similar to the Irish Confederation his Young Irelanders formed to lobby for Irish representation in Great Britain, in the 1840’s.  On the other hand, Meagher became enamored with the prospect of being in an all Irish regiment from New York.  After the firing on Fort Sumter, the Irish American published an article backing Abraham Lincoln’s defense of the Union, “Irish Americans, we call on you…to be true to the land of your adoption in this crisis.”  Robert Nugent, lieutenant colonel of the 69th, speaking with Meagher, who expressed his abhorrence to the firing on Sumpter urged him, “As you feel that way, Mr. Meagher, perhaps you might take a notion of coming with us.”(i)

Meagher decided to join Corcoran who asked him to stay behind and raise another company before joining him in Washington City.  In little more than a week, the 38 year old Meagher had filled his company.  Outfitted in bright French Algerian styled uniforms the company became known as the Irish Zouaves.  Meagher was commissioned captain of the company and left New York City, to join the rest of the 69th, on May 22.  Shortly after joining Colonel Corcoran, Meagher would be promoted to major.

By early June, the Lincoln Administration, the northern populace and many of the soldiers were ready to go and whip the Rebels.  Assigned to Colonel William Tecumseh Sherman’s brigade, who at this time was not well known, the 69th New York Militia would learn quickly the ways of the army.  Sherman went strictly by the book.  While Sherman had spent some years away from the army, he had graduated sixth from West Point, in 1840.  He would drill his brigade continuously, due to his concern with the reliability of volunteer militia units.  Also brigaded with the 69th were several other New York units: 13th, 29th and 79th regiments.  Lastly, one western regiment, the 2d Wisconsin was also assigned to the brigade.  Like the 69th New York, the 2d Wisconsin would also become part of a famous brigade – the Iron Brigade.  However, in the early summer of 1861, these troops were “green” and were more accustomed to military parade than fighting a hostile enemy.

The U.S. troops garrisoned around Washington City were part of the Army of Northeastern Virginia.  Commanded by US Brigadier General Irvin McDowell, they were the largest army unit ever organized on American soil, to that point.  Sherman commanded the Third Brigade in the Army’s First Division – one of the largest brigades in the army.  Facing them was the Confederate Army of the Potomac, commanded by the hero of Fort Sumter, CSA Brigadier General Pierre Gustave Toutant (P.G.T.) Beauregard.  A career military man, and an 1838 graduate of West Point, Beauregard had approximately 15,000 soldiers under his command, which were positioned along Bull Run Creek, just north of the vital railroad hub at Manassas Station.(ii)  In the Shenandoah Valley, the Confederates had approximately 11,000 soldiers, in three brigades, commanded by CSA General Joseph E. Johnston, one of the highest ranking officers in the Confederate service.  By early July, Lincoln began to pressure McDowell to move out of the Washington defenses, and attack Beauregard, before Johnston could reinforce him.  With nearly 30,000 men, of all arms, Lincoln knew his army enjoyed a significant numerical superiority and believed McDowell could crush Beauregard.  McDowell was concerned about how his “green” troops would perform, under fire, and expressed these concerns to Lincoln.  Lincoln assured him, “You are green, it is true, but they are green also.  You are green alike.”(iii)

On July 16, the Army of Northeastern Virginia vacated their fortifications and pushed southwest towards the Bull Run.  Upon reaching the area of Centreville, Virginia, McDowell changed his battle plan.  He would hold the Confederate left flank, at the Stone Bridge, on the Warrenton Turnpike, with the majority of Brigadier General Daniel Tyler’s division, while skirmishing along the Confederate left flank, near Blackburn’s Ford, with two brigades (colonels Israel Richardson and Thomas Davies) would hold Beauregard’s right flank place.  These tactical operations were part of a diversion to allow two Federal divisions, commanded colonels David Hunter and Samuel Heitzlman, to push north, crossing the Bull Run at Sudley’s Ford, and fall on the exposed left flank of the Confederate Army of the Potomac.  McDowell’s plans were well conceived, but he underestimated the ability of his army to coordinate such complicated moves at the proper time.  This would prove fatal for the Federals’ hopes of ending the war on the fields near Manassas Junction.  It would also cost countless lives, including 192 casualties in the 69th New York Militia.(iv)

By 2:30 a.m. Tyler’s Division had started their flanking march and were expected to push across Sudley’s Ford by 7:00 a.m.  Due to difficulty moving such large troop formations, Tyler’s division was unable to cross Bull Run at the planned hour and did not push across until nearly 9:30 a.m.  CSA Colonel Nathan Evans, holding the Confederate left flank, quickly recognized that McDowell’s plans were not for an attack across the Stone Bridge, but an attack, from the north, that would flank his position.  Leaving behind four companies of the 4th South Carolina, to hold the Stone Bridge, Evans quickly marched the rest of his brigade west to meet Tyler’s Federals.  Placing his soldiers on the reverse slope of Matthews Hill, he prepared for the inevitable.  The opposing forces would clash at 10:15 a.m.  For next 90 minutes Evans, reinforced by two brigades from Johnston’s Army of the Shenandoah (Francis S. Bartow and Barnard E. Bee), would hold their position against a numerically superior Federal force.  Finally being pushed off Matthews Hill, around 11:45 a.m., the Confederates would retreat south to Henry Hill.  There they would be reinforced by CSA Brigadier General Thomas Jackson’s Brigade, creating a strong defensive position.

For the next two hours the Federals fought to capture Henry Hill.  They would suffer heavy casualties at the junction of the Warrenton Turnpike and the Sudley-Manassas Road.  The 69th New York, along with the rest of Sherman’s brigade, would be pressed into action while the Confederate forces were retreating from Matthews Hill.  Pushing across the Bull Run, at Farm Road, they would be placed in reserve, behind the rest of Tyler’s Division, which was being thrown into action regiment, by regiment.  Around Fighting 69th at Bull Run by Don Troiani2:00 p.m., it was Sherman’s turn to enter the action.  Pushing his brigade down the Sudley-Manassas Road, he would attack the Confederate position from the west, south of the Warrenton Turnpike.  For nearly two hours his brigade, including the 69th New York, would battle the Confederates on the high ground of Henry Hill.  They would suffer severely from infantry and artillery fire.  By 4:00 p.m., they would be forced to retreat north towards Sudley’s Ford.  McDowell, who appeared to have victory within his reach, after the Confederate retreat from Matthews Hill, found his army in full retreat.  The 69th New York’s first taste of battle would be costly, as the first battle of Bull Run ended in a Federal rout, with the Army of Northeastern Virginia rapidly retreating towards Washington City.  Entrusted with the 69th New York Militia’s battle flag, was Meagher’s Company K of Irish Zouaves.  With his sword extended over his head, Meagher encouraged his soldiers, “Boys, look at that flag – think of Ireland and Fontenoy.”  This battle flag had been captured by the Confederates, with two color bearers killed, before being recaptured by John Wildey of the New York Fire Zouaves.  A soldier from Company K stated passionately, “…not on this continent a braver man than Thomas Francis Meagher.”(v)  Meagher’s star had begun to shine in his regiment.

On July 25, four days after First Bull Run, the 90 day enlistment period for the 69th New York Militia expired.  Leaving Washington City, they would pass through Baltimore and Philadelphia, where admiring crowds cheered them along.  When they reached New York City, they would be escorted up Broadway with an admiring throng cheering for them, and a 69 gun salute from a three gun battery.(vi)

With the 69th New York Militia officially mustered out of Federal service, the respite would indeed be brief for many of the soldiers.  Meagher, speaking at Jones’ Wood, asked for financial support for the widows and orphans of the men who did not return.  He also used his oratorical skills to begin recruiting for the 69th New York Volunteer Infantry.  Now a colonel, Meagher declined to take command of the new 69th, with regimental command being given to Colonel Robert Nugent.  Meagher was on a mission to create an all Irish Brigade to serve in the newly christened Army of the Potomac, under the command of US Major General George B. McClellan.

Thomas F. MeagherMeagher’s plans were to have two New York regiments and one from each, Philadelphia and Boston.  His plans derailed as the governors of Massachusetts and Pennsylvania did not want to detail regiments to be sent to New York – fearing they may be attributed to those states.  With throngs of New York Irish enlisting at the Irish Brigade recruiting station, on Broadway, the original Irish Brigade would be composed of the 63d, 69th and 88th New York infantry regiments. Additionally the 2d Battalion New York Artillery was also attached to the brigade.  Filling the 69th New Yorks depleted ranks were companies from Brooklyn, Buffalo and Chicago.  With the 69th being the first to reach regimental strength, it would be designated the First Regiment, Irish Brigade.  They would receive a battle flag, produced by Tiffany and Company, that was emerald green, with a harp suspended by bright sun rays.  Their regimental motto was inscribed at the bottom of the flag, “Who never retreated from the clash of spears.”(vii)  Most soldiers in the regiment would receive smooth bore Prussian made .69 caliber muskets.  Additionally there were close to 300 Enfield rifled muskets distributed from the cache of arms brought back from Virginia.  All told, the 69th New York would have 745 soldiers – slightly under full strength.

The new 69th would be officially mustered into Federal service on November 18, 1861 and would immediately leave for Washington City.  The 63d and 88th New York regiments would follow the 69th after the 88th was mustered into Federal service on December 16, 1861.(viii)  Upon arriving at Camp California, near Alexandria, Virginia, they would join the 69th and would be under the nominal command of Colonel Nugent until February 1862, when Meagher arrived in Washington City.  Meagher would be commissioned brigadier general on February 3, 1862 and officially supplant Nugent as commander of the Irish Brigade on February 5.(ix)  Over the next several months, during the winter of 1862, the Irish Brigade would be drilled, marched and organized, with the rest of the Army of the Potomac, by McClellan who had earned the moniker, “Young Napoleon.”  With 140 plus years of historical analysis, McClellan’s faults have been well documented.  However, his organizational skills, drilling and inspired leadership were his hallmark and would provide the 69th New York, and the rest of the Army of the Potomac, fundamental skills they would need during the rapidly approaching 1862 campaign season.

As the winter months of 1862 were waning, the Lincoln administration was becoming anxious to learn what McClellan’s plans were for the coming months.  “On to Richmond” was continually in the North’s newspaper headlines, with the public anxious for action – an action they believed would end the war with the capture of the Confederate capital.  Lincoln preferred an overland route for his eastern theater army, while McClellan believed the best route was to head down the Potomac, Disembarking at Urbanna, Virginia with one strong push towards Richmond.  Both plans had merit, and both had inherent risk.  The overland route, across the Rappahannock River, would be more direct, and would allow McClellan to use nearly his entire army, as Washington could easily be defended.  Supplying McClellan’s massive 100,000+ man army would require significant military outposts to guard the long supply line.  McClellan’s proposed “Urbanna Plan” which would use ships to carry his entire army to Urbanna, Virginia, at the confluence of the Rappahannock and Potomac Rivers, would allow the Federal army to quickly flank Joseph Johnston’s Army of Northern Virginia.  Lincoln had serious reservations about this plan, as it would leave Washington uncovered and open to attack by the Confederate army.  However, the Urbanna Plan allowed the Federal Army to use the inland waterways to supply their men.  The plan would finally be approved by Lincoln, when on March 8, McClellan and eleven other generals met with Lincoln at the White House.  III Corps commander, US Brigadier General Samuel Heintzelman noted in his diary that day, “He (Lincoln) urged us all to go in heartily for this plan.”(x)  Lincoln, however, placed certain restrictions on McClellan.  No more than two corps would be sailed from Annapolis until all enemy batteries, on the upper Potomac, were cleared.  Additionally, the capital must be left entirely secure and the army must begin their movements by March 18.

About this same time, the Federal government had learned that Joe Johnston had pulled his troops from the Centreville-Leesburg line and had moved to a position south of the Rappahannock River.  This made the Urbanna Plan unworkable as Johnston’s army would be on their flank at Urbanna.  McClellan changed his plans and opted to use Fort Monroe, on the Virginia peninsula, as his staging point.  From their the Army of the Potomac would push up the peninsula towards Richmond.  This change created what would become the Peninsula Campaign.

On March 17, the II, III and IV Army Corps began leaving Annapolis.  Huge amounts of ships were used to transport McClellan’s infantry, artillery, cavalry and baggage trains.  On April 4, with his three army corps, McClellan pushed up the Virginia peninsula.  Over the coming weeks, the Army of the Potomac, would be further reinforced by the V and VI Army Corps.  They would fight battles at Yorktown (siege), Williamsburg, Eltham’s Landing, Drewry’s Bluff, Hanover Court House and Seven Pines, pushing within sight of the city of Richmond.  Prior to leaving Annapolis, The Irish Brigade, along with the 69th New York Infantry, were assigned to US Brigadier General Israel B. Richardson’s First Division, of US Brigadier General Edwin V. Sumner’s II Army Corps.  Arriving before Yorktown, the 69th was used to corduroy roads (covering muddy roads with large logs) and digging gun emplacements.  As Yorktown turned into a siege, the Irishmen did not see significant action at there.  Pushing west, the Army of the Potomac would next encounter the Confederate forces at Williamsburg.  The Irish Brigade would arrive too late to participate in the fighting here.  Sent back to Yorktown, the Irish Brigade would board transport ships and move to West Point, on the York River.  Moving further inland, the Army of the Potomac’s next significant battle took place at Seven Pines (also called Fair Oaks) from May 31 – June 1.  With US Brigadier General Erasmus Keyes’ IV Corps bearing the brunt of the Confederate attack, it would be virtually Irish Brigade at Fair Oakswrecked.  With word of the battle, reaching West Point, the Irish Brigade would quickly be put into motion crossing the rickety Grapevine Bridge and marching through the night to reach the battlefield.  Meagher would leave the 63d New York behind, to guard the bridge, in the event they needed it for further movements.  The rest of the brigade would arrive, to the sound of sporadic musketry, at 9:00 p.m., on May 31.  Exhausted, they would have little sleep before being awakened at 4:00 a.m.(xi)  Meagher, already on his horse, was able to view the grisly remnants on the previous day’s fight.  The Irish Brigade’s chaplain, Father William Corby described the scene, “Many a poor soldier lay cold in death just where he fell in the battle of the previous evening, and we saw the ghastly appearance of their bodies, which had been, as it were, our bed-fellows, and a shudder passed through our hearts…. Taking a hasty look over the locality, I saw on every side dead men, dead horses, broken muskets, caissons smashed to pieces, and the general destruction of life and property.(xii)

With the Army of the Potomac, now forming a right angle, with the right arm posted along Hanover Road, and the left arm positioned above the Richmond and York River Railroad, east of Fair Oaks Station, the battle lines were drawn for the second day of fighting at Seven Pines.  Meagher’s two regiments (88th and 69th) were positioned in the center of the left arm, above Orchard Station.  After receiving orders from Richardson, Meagher pushed the 69th into action, ordering them down the hill, to the railroad tracks.  They quickly encountered fire from CSA Brigadier General Lewis Armistead’s Brigade, which was well hidden in the woods, and buildings, above the railroad cut.  With the 69th heavily engaged, Richardson ordered the 88th New York to the left flank of the 69th.  However, the order would be countermanded before the entire 88th could push through the underbrush, to the railroad.  Unfortunately, this left the 69th and two companies of the 88th, to fend for themselves.  They would be quickly overwhelmed and forced to retreat, leaving dead and wounded where they had fallen.  Meagher led his troops bravely with a staff member recalling, “(Meagher was) indefatigable, riding from line to line, cheering on the men.  The general was all the time under fire.”(xiii)  All told, during the Battle of Fair Oaks, which was inconclusive, with both armies holding their original position, the Army of the Potomac would suffer 5,700 casualties.  The Confederates would suffer nearly 8,000, including their commander, Joseph E. Johnston, who left the battlefield seriously wounded.  He would spend months recovering, while CSA General Robert E. Lee would permanently take over command of the Army of Northern Virginia.

The Irish Brigade would receive reinforcements, after the Battle of Fair Oaks, when the 29th Massachusetts was assigned to Meagher’s command.  While not an “Irish” regiment, they were welcomed into the depleted brigade by the Irishmen. 

Irish Brigade at Gaines' MillOn June 27, with just Brigadier General Fitz John Porter’s V Corps, north of the Chickahominy River, Lee would assault the lone Federal corps at the Battle of Gaines’ Mill – the opening salvo of the Seven Days.  Struggling through the day, Porter’s Corps fought bravely.  Meagher’s Irish Brigade and US Brigadier General William French’s brigade were sent north to reinforce Porter.  With the “Fighting 69th” leading the way, the Irish Brigade was able to stem the quickly developing V Corps rout, and join the battle at Gaines’ Mill.  They would march to the right flank, allowing the Federals to hold their position until they were able to cross the Chickahominy and rejoin the rest of the Army of the Potomac.  The Irishmen acted as a rear guard, crossing the river early the next morning.(xiv)  Fortunately, the Confederates did not follow up their victory, letting the Federals retreat unmolested after suffering nearly 7,000 casualties.

McClellan, already having planned a change of base, to the York River, quickly began moving his massive army south.  On June 29, Sumner’s II Corps would be attacked while maintaining the army’s rear guard, at Savage’s Station.  Again, the Irish Brigade was thrown into the fight.  Sumner, being harassed by artillery fire, would send the 88th New York to silence an artillery battery that blocked their path on the Williamsburg Road.  US Major James Quinlan would lead the charge, with the regiment receiving a blast of cannister before the Confederate artillery limbered up retreating to their lines.  Quinlan would receive the Medal of Honor for his actions at Savage’s Station.  Meanwhile, the 69th New York would repel a Confederate probe against their lines.  Once again, the Irish Brigade performed nobly.  The Army of the Potomac would continue its retreat, this time to White Oak Swamp, after leaving nearly 2,500 wounded soldiers at a field hospital.  At White Oak Swamp (also called Glendale or Frayser’s Farm), on June 30, the Irish Brigade would once again be in the rear guard.  Pulling up, on the far side of the swamp, Meagher would deploy his line, protecting the retreating Army of the Potomac.  With Confederate artillery pounding them, they would hold them in place, until they could pull back and join the rest of the army at Malvern Hill.

Malvern Hill, a readily defensible plateau, became the new Federal defensive line, allowing the Army of the Potomac to continue its retreat to Harrison’s Landing.  Manned by Porter’s V Corps, and significant Federal artillery, Malvern Hill proved too much for the Confederates.  On July 1, at the Battle of Malvern Hill, Lee would throw successive waves of infantry assaults against the V Corps, and would be repulsed each time.  Late in the day, while the Irish Brigade was preparing to eat dinner, they would be called upon to support the V Corps, whose left flank was beginning to crumble under a massive assault by CSA Major General John Magruder’s Reserve divisions.  Quickly forming and pushing towards Porter’s left flank, the 63d New York and 29th Massachusetts were detailed to support an artillery Irish Brigade at Malvern Hillbattery.  The veteran 69th and 88th New York were sent into a woodlot, on the left, where Porter believed he may be flanked.  Within moments, they received heavy fire from the rapidly approaching 10th Louisiana “Fighting Tigers” Infantry.  While suffering numerous casualties, the 69th not only held their position, but charged the Confederate force.  They would move to the right, allowing the 88th to move on their left flank.  The two regiments would continue to fight until dark, nearly running out of ammunition and with their muskets so hot and fouled that they were forced to fight hand-to-hand.  A staff officer, describing the charge of the 69th and 88th New York against the Louisiana Tigers stated, “(what a) grand sight!  These two regiments side by side like brothers in a fight, moving in and out, the one to relieve the other when their weapons became almost impossible to work.”(xv)  With their strong stand, on the left flank, the Irish Brigade was able to help hold the Federal left flank, leading to Federal victory at Malvern Hill.  The 69th would bear the brunt of the casualties with 155 total, while the 88th would suffer a total of 33 casualties.  Once again, Meagher’s Irish Brigade performed admirably.  Finally, joining the rest of the army at Harrison’s Landing, the Seven Days battles were over.  The Peninsula Campaign and Seven Days battles decimated the ranks of the proud Irish Brigade.  All told, the three New York regiments suffered 460 casualties in their nearly three month “baptism of fire.”  On July 16, McClellan ordered Meagher to return to New York, to recruit reinforcements for his shattered brigade.

With their general in New York City, the Irish Brigade stayed at Harrison’s Landing with the rest of the Army of the Potomac.  The Army of the Potomac would begin boarding transport ships around the middle of August.  No longer announcing “On To Richmond,” the newspapers were now writing about a gathering storm in Northern Virginia.  After pulling back from Malvern Hill, Lee returned to the fortifications near Richmond.  With the newly constituted Army of Virginia, commanded by US Major General John Pope, threatening central Virginia, Lee dispatched a large portion of his army, under the command of Major General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson north, to prevent the Army of Virginia from combining with the Army of the Potomac.  Jackson, and the Army of Northern Virginia, would win successive battles, first at Cedar Mountain on August 9, and then at Second Manassas where Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia would totally rout Pope’s Army of Virginia, August 28–30.  With McClellan’s troops in transit to Alexandria, only Porter’s V Corps would reach the field in time to reinforce Pope.  Accused of holding reinforcements from Pope, McClellan would nearly be removed from command.  Once Pope’s shattered army reached Washington, parts of it would be consolidated into the Army of the Potomac, with McClellan placed in command of an even larger army.  In the meantime, Lee started north, embarking on what would be known as the Maryland Campaign.

Meagher’s recruiting trip, to New York City, was not nearly as successful as previous recruiting trips.  Speaking at the 7th Regiment Armory, Meagher encouraged the Irish with a dazzling speech, “I here this night call upon my countrymen…to throw themselves forward, and pledging themselves in life and death to it, to stand to the last by that noble little brigade.”(xvi)  Hoping to bring in 1,000 new recruits, Meagher left to rejoin the Army of the Potomac with little more than 300.

With Lee crossing the Potomac River, into Maryland, on September 4, 1862, McClellan pushed his huge army northwest to Frederick, Maryland.  On September 14, with US Major General Joseph Hooker’s I Corps engaged at South Mountain, the Irish Brigade was ordered from Frederick to support him.  By the time they were able to reach South Mountain, the Confederates were already retreating west.  The Irish Brigade, leading the Federal pursuit from South Mountain pushed through Boonsborough and Keedysville before it was posted on the east side of Antietam Creek, in support of Federal artillery.  It was September 16.

On the morning of September 17, the Army of the Potomac attacked Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia, which was posted on the west side of the creek.  Initiated by an early morning attack through the Corn Field, by Hooker’s I Corps, the battle quickly heated up.  After several hours of fighting on Hooker’s front, Sumner’s II Corps was pushed into action around 10:00 a.m.  With Major General William French’s Third Division on the left, and Major General Israel Richardson’s First Division on the right, they pushed onto the battlefield.  However, instead of pushing west to reinforce Hooker, they began to veer to the left, pushing towards a sunken road, baptized in blood as Bloody Lane.  Pushing up a hill, near the Roulette Farm, the Irish Brigade was ordered into line of battle, with 69th New York on the right, followed by the 29th Massachusetts, 63d New York and the 88th New York on the brigade’s left flank.  Ordered to lead the division towards the growing sounds of battle, the Irish Brigade pushed up the hill, followed by US Brigadier General John Caldwell’s First Brigade.  As the brigade reached the crest of the hill, silhouetted from behind, they became an easy target for the Confederates in the sunken road.  Meagher ordered his brigade to fire into the Confederates below them.  Equipped with smooth bore muskets, firing buck-and-ball (like a shotgun), many of the Confederates would fall under this first volley.  With a yell, from Meagher, “Boys, raise the colors and follow me!” the Irish Brigade rushed towards the Bloody Lane.(xvii)

Irish Brigade at AntietamFacing them, on the Confederate side, were Confederate brigades commanded by CSA Brigadier Generals George B. Anderson and Ambrose R. Wright.  With the Federal forces reeling from the withering Rebel fire, Wright sent his brigade headlong into the Irish Brigade’s left flank, the 88th and 63d New York bearing the brunt of the assault.  The buck-and-ball melted them away, and they returned to the main Confederate line.  By this time, the Irish Brigade was the only brigade of Richardson’s division in the fight.  The battle at the sunken road would rage for over two hours.  Richardson would send in John Caldwell’s First Brigade to support the Irish Brigade.  With support at hand, the Irish Brigade pushed to the rear.  With Caldwell’s fresh brigade in the action, the Confederates were forced to pull back to the high ground of the Piper Farm, beyond the sunken road.  After the Battle of Antietam, Meagher stated, “Never were men in higher spirits.  Never did men with such alacrity and generosity of heart press forward and encounter the perils of the battle-field.”(xviii)  During the fighting at the Bloody Lane, the Irish Brigade would suffer a casualty rate approaching 60%.  The Fighting 69th New York would sustain the most casualties of any of the Irish Brigade regiments with 196 total casualties – 44 killed.  Included in this number were a total of eight color bearers who fell carrying the green Irish Brigade flag.  The 63d New York would suffer nearly as many with 192 total casualties.  The 88th New York, on the brigade’s left flank would incur 102 casualties.  The Irish Brigade continued to enhance its reputation as one of the hardest fighting brigades in the Army of the Potomac.  Unfortunately, Meagher was shrouded in controversy after Antietam.  According to a soldier in the 132d Pennsylvania volunteers, “…the Irish Brigade came up, under the command of General Thomas Francis Meagher.  Meagher rode a beautiful white horse, but made a show of himself by tumbling off just as he reached our line.  The boys said he was drunk, and he certainly looked and acted like a drunken man.”(ixx)  The rumors would circulate in the press, and amongst the soldiers, that Meagher was intoxicated during the battle.  McClellan’s official report of Antietam did not mention Meagher’s reported drunkenness, but the controversy would haunt Meagher for the remainder of his short life.

After the battle of Antietam, Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia retreated across the Potomac.  McClellan would remain in the vicinity of Antietam for an extended period.  Abraham Lincoln would use the quasi victory, which history has deemed a draw, as a occasion to issue his Emancipation Proclamation – effectively changing the war aim from saving the Union to freeing the slaves.  Over the coming weeks, McClellan would finally begin his pursuit of Lee.  However, it was not quickly enough for Lincoln who, on November 7, 1862, placed US Major General Ambrose E. Burnside in command of the Army of the Potomac.  McClellan was told to remove himself to his home state of New Jersey to await further orders – orders that never came.  His army career was over even though he remained on the active army rolls.

Shortly after taking command, Burnside organized his Army of the Potomac into three Grand Divisions, commanded by Major Generals Edwin V. Sumner, Joseph Hooker and William B. Franklin.  The Irish Brigade was assigned to Sumner’s Right Grand Division.  Major General Darius Couch would command his II Corps while Brigadier General Winfield S. Hancock commanded the First Division of which the Irish Brigade was designated the Second Brigade.  After its mauling at Antietam, the Irish Brigade was under strength.  The 116th Pennsylvania would be added to the brigade to supplement the brigade’s losses.  Commanded by Colonel Dennis Heenan, the regiment’s Hibernian roots did not extend below its officers.  Most of the non-commissioned soldiers had Pennsylvania Dutch surnames.  Regardless, the brigade welcomed the men.

Burnside wasted no time making plans to thwart Lee.  With his army bivouacked near Warrenton, Virginia, he planned to feint a movement towards Culpeper – freezing the Army of the Potomac in place.  With Lee defending the Culpeper-Gordonsville line, he planned to quickly move towards Falmouth, crossing into Fredericksburg where the route to Richmond would be open along Richmond, Fredericksburg and Potomac Railroad.  Leaving the Warrenton area, on November 15, the lead elements of Burnside’s 114,000 man army arrived in Falmouth on November 17.  Expecting to have his pontoon bridges waiting for him, Burnside learned that there was a mixup at the War Department that caused them to be delayed.  Lee was initially confused by Burnside’s movement and did not get his Army of Northern Virginia into motion for several days.  By November 21, CSA Lieutenant General James Longstreet’s 1st Corps had arrived in Fredericksburg, digging in along Marye’s Heights, above the town.  It was not until December 11 that Burnside’s engineers began constructing six pontoon bridges across the Rappahannock River.  By then, Lee had ordered Lieutenant General Thomas Jackson’s 2d Corps back to Fredericksburg, from a river crossing south of Fredericksburg.  On December 13, 1862, with Lee’s entire army entrenched beyond Fredericksburg, Franklin’s Left Grand Division opened the Battle of Fredericksburg by attacking the Confederate right flank, commanded by Jackson, at Prospect Hill.  With the initial assault by US Major General George Meade’s division taking place at 8:30 a.m., the Federal army experienced some early success.  Unfortunately, Franklin sent his I Corps in, one division at a time, with little coordination between the forces.  The attack would grind to a halt, during the early afternoon, with neither side gaining any ground.

On the other side of the battlefield, Sumner’s Right Grand Division began its attack around 11:00 a.m.  Sending the II Corps division of William French through the town of Fredericksburg, they moved across the open ground to attack Longstreet’s 1st Corps.  Longstreet had established an extremely strong position above town, on Marye’s Heights.  With CSA Colonel John B. Walton’s Washington (Louisiana) Artillery arrayed near the top of the heights, and three infantry brigades below the artillery, Longstreet was confident of his defensive position.  The defining feature of his position was a sunken road that ran along the base of the hill, with a stone wall between the road and the Federal approach path.  CSA Colonel Edward Porter Alexander described the situation, “A chicken could not live upon that field when we open upon it.”(xx)  Earlier in the day, Walton had issued orders to his Washington Artillery, “As soon as the enemy’s infantry comes in range of your long-range guns General Longstreet wishes you to open upon them with effect.  Be particular in acquiring the bearing and range of the streets of town.  The enemy passing through them will give you an opportunity to rake him, which you of course will take.”(xxi)  Walton’s artillerists did not disappoint.  With French’s division pushing through town, they immediately began receiving fire from the Washington Artillery.  The artillery was well aimed, with the correct range, and opened large gaps in French’s division that would be immediately closed, before being opened again by additional artillery shells.  As they began to cross the field, below Marye’s Heights, the Confederate artillery would start firing canister into the approaching troops.  Again, closing ranks, they would continue to push up the hill.  Meanwhile, CSA Brigadier General Thomas R.R. Cobb admonished his troops, in the sunken road, to hold their fire until, “you can count the Yankee buttons.”  They did not have to wait long.  Once French’s division had approached within range, Cobb’s infantry opened fire, the musketry creating, “a perfect sheet of flame…from behind the stone wall.”(xxii)  The fire was more than the Federal infantry could endure.  Those soldiers that had survived the trek through town, and up the hill, laid down to avoid the fire.  Others hid behind buildings.

Following French, was Hancock’s First Division, which included the Irish Brigade.  Being able to watch the battle above them, Meagher distributed sprigs of green box elder to each Irishman to allow them to identify members of the brigade, that were not near the colors, as they pushed through the other II Corps troops engaged along the approach to Marye’s Heights.  With US Colonel Samuel Zook’s First Brigade leading the Irish Brigade at Fredericksburgway, the Irish Brigade fell in behind them.  With Zook’s brigade vaporizing before them, the Irish Brigade began to move at the double quick.  After crossing a mill race, under heavy fire, Meagher stopped his brigade and dressed ranks forming in line of battle.  With the 69th New York on the right flank, the rest of the brigade formed on their left - 88th New York, 29th Massachusetts, 63d New York and 116th Pennsylvania.  With all of the brigade’s field officers on foot, they immediately pushed forward to the stone wall - and the sheet of flame emanating from the Confederate muskets.  The Confederates knew the Irish were coming when they saw the 29th Massachusetts “green flag with the golden harp of old Ireland.”  With artillery canister tearing huge gaps in their ranks the Irish Brigade continued to move towards the wall, stepping over, and around, soldiers who had previously been injured, or killed, trying to reach the wall.  After moving across a fence, the infantry opened on the brigade, decimating its ranks.  A few lone soldiers, including Major William Horgan and adjutant John Young, of the 88th New York, continued to push forward alone, before they were killed within a few feet of the wall.  One Confederate officer recalled that the Irish “pushed on beyond all former charges, and fought and left their dead between five and twenty paces of the sunken road.”(xxiii)  The brigade’s survivors dropped to the ground, in a small depression, to escape the storm of lead.

Following the Irish Brigade was Caldwell’s First Brigade, which suffered the same fate as all the other brigades thrown against the Confederates on Marye’s Heights.  Burnside, still not satisfied that the Confederate position was unassailable pushed another division into the grinder.  With most of the entire II Corps dead, wounded, retreating or laying prone on the field, US Brigadier General Andrew Humphreys’ V Corps division pushed up Marye’s Heights.  Their fate was the same as each division, brigade and regiment engaged against the Confederates on Marye’s Heights – they were slaughtered.  Thus ended the debacle of Fredericksburg.  With most of the soldiers still strewn across the fields in front of Marye’s Heights, nightfall would end all but sporadic fighting.  Since the weather had been unseasonably warm, most of the soldiers had left behind their coats and blankets.  Unfortunately for the shattered humanity exposed to the elements, in front of Longstreet’s 1st Corps, the weather turned bitterly cold.  Many men, near death, would die from exposure.  Others would try to stay warm by huddling with other soldiers, all the while under sniper fire.  The 69th would lose sixteen of its commissioned officers – all that had charged Marye’s Heights.  Amongst the non-commissioned officers, it was just as grim as only 61 of the 173 enlisted men would survive unscathed.  After the battle of Fredericksburg, only 263 men, of the five Irish Brigade regiments, answered roll call.  A London Times reporter with the Confederate army summed it up best, “…never was more undoubted courage displayed by the sons of Erin than during those six frantic dashes which they directed against an almost impregnable position of their foe.”(xxiv)

In the spring of 1863, the Army of the Potomac had another new commander.  Center Grand Division commander Joseph Hooker took command of the army after Ambrose Burnside offered his resignation to Lincoln.  Burnside thinking Lincoln would refuse his resignation found out otherwise.  Unlike his predecessor, George B. McClellan, Burnside would stay in the army, commanding the IX Corps, assigned to the Department of the Ohio in east Tennessee.  Meagher petitioned to return to New York, with the 69th, 63d and 88th regiments, to re-fit and fill the ranks.  He would be turned down.  The Irish Brigade celebrated St. Patrick’s Day 1863 in style.  Even Joe Hooker came to the celebration. 

With the campaign season nearing, Hooker planned his offensive.  Ever aggressive, he planned to hold “Bobby” Lee’s army in Fredericksburg, with US Major General John Sedgwick’s VI Corps, while he marched his other six army corps west, along the Rappahannock River, ultimately flanking Lee and falling on his rear, between Fredericksburg and Richmond.  Beginning on April 27, he put his plans in motion marching west along the Rappahannock with Meade’s V Corps, US Major General Oliver O. Howard’s XI Corps and US Major General Henry Slocum’s XII Corps.  Crossing the Rappahannock River at Kelly’s Ford, they would push south to Ely’s Ford to cross the Rapidan River.  From there they pushed east towards Chancellorsville.  Darius Couch’s II Corps, led by Meagher’s small Irish Brigade, less the 88th New York, pushed north crossing the Rappahannock River at U.S. Ford, arriving from the north near the Chancellor Tavern. 

Early on May 1, Lee determined what Hooker’s true intentions were and quickly sent CSA Major General Lafayette McLaw’s 1st Corps Division to meet the growing threat on his left flank.  They would run into portions of Couch’s II Corps, and Meade’s V Corps, along the Orange Turnpike east of Chancellorsville.  Jackson’s 2d Corps would be sent a short time later, and would meet Slocum’s XII Corps along the Orange Plank Road.  Overnight, Lee and Jackson held their last meeting, behind the Confederate lines.  Learning that Howard’s XI Corps was on the far right Federal flank, and unprepared for an attack from the west, they determined that Jackson would take his entire corps on a long flanking march early on May 2.  Starting later than planned, Jackson would pulverize Howard’s XI Corps around 5:30 p.m.  This turned into a rout, with the XI Corps retreating east, towards the Chancellor Tavern.  Hooker, being injured by an artillery shell, turned the Federal position at Chancellorsville over to Couch.  Shortening their lines, and consolidating their position near the Chancellor Tavern, the two sides would fight until darkness ended the fighting for the day.  Meagher’s Irish Brigade, hearing the fighting, organized their lines.  Overnight, while scouting ahead of his lines, Stonewall Jackson, and CSA Major General A.P. Hill, would be injured by friendly fire.  Jackson would die on May 10 from pneumonia, caused by his weakened condition.  This would be a tremendous loss for Lee, who put CSA Major General J.E.B. Stuart in charge of Jackson’s 2d Corps.

On May 3, the battle around the Chancellor Inn would start again.  The Irish Brigade, held in reserve, would be pushed into action by 8:00 a.m., to attempt to shore up the deteriorating Federal lines, on the east side of the Federal salient.  The Irish Brigade would again fight bravely, helping hold the Union position throughout the day.  The 88th New York would also be called up to support Caldwell’s First Brigade.  Overnight, Couch determined to retreat north of the Rappahannock, using U.S. Ford, ending the Battle of Chancellorsville – another terrible Federal defeat – and Robert E. Lee’s most brilliant victory.  While the total casualty count for the Irish Brigade was only 56, it was a high casualty rate for such a small brigade.  The 116th Pennsylvania was so depleted it would be reorganized into a four company battalion.  Meagher would resign his commission while the three New York regiments would be consolidated into three two-company battalions.  On June 14, US Colonel Patrick Kelly would lead the remnants of the Irish Brigade north from the Rappahannock River line.

Robert E. Lee, again wanting to take the war north of the Mason-Dixon Line, pushed through the Shenandoah Valley into Maryland and Pennsylvania, arriving in late June.  Hooker, pursuing Lee’s army east of South Mountain, would be relieved of command on June 28.  Replacing Hooker was George Meade, who had to determine Lee’s intent.  On July 1, an advanced U.S. Cavalry division, commanded by US Brigadier General John Buford, engaged Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.  During the first day’s battle, Buford’s cavalry, reinforced by US Major General John F. Reynolds’ I Corps, and Oliver O. Howard’s XI Corps, would hold their position, northwest of Gettysburg, until they were finally pushed south of town, to Culp’s Hill and Cemetery Ridge.  II Corps’ commander, Winfield S. Hancock, would take command of the Federal position and await the arrival of his II Corps, overnight.

On the morning of July 2, the Federal line resembled a “fish hook,” stretching from Culp’s Hill, on the north, to Little Round Top on the south.  That afternoon, Lee ordered James Longstreet’s 1st Corps to attack the Federal left flank.  By then, US Major General Daniel E. Sickles’ III Corps had Father Corby at Gettysburgmoved over a mile forward of the Union lines, creating a huge salient.  Two of Longstreet’s Divisions, commanded by Major Generals Lafayette McLaw’s and John Bell Hood, slammed into Sickles’ exposed left flank.  With US Major General George Sykes’ V Corps defending Little Round Top, Sickles’ III Corps engaged Longstreet’s divisions at the Devil’s Den, and the Wheatfield.  Meade, after surveying Sickles’ forward position, ordered Hancock to send reinforcements from his II Corps.  Hancock chose US Brigadier General John Caldwell’s First Division, which included Patrick Kelly’s Irish Brigade, and three additional brigades commanded by US Brigadier General Samuel Zook and Colonels Edward Cross and John Brooke.  Before their march towards the Wheat Field, the Irish Brigade’s chaplain, Father William Corby, performed the surreal act of providing the soldiers with conditional absolution.  Standing on a rock, with his right hand outstretched over his flock, he performed the quick service.  His general absolution was, “intended for all – in quantum possum – not only for our brigade, but for all, North and South, who were susceptible of it and who were about to appear before their Judge.”  The ever profane Hancock, sitting on his horse, removed his hat in an act of reverence.(xxv)  Immediately afterwards, Cross’ brigade, followed by the Irish Brigade, Brooke’s brigade and Zook’s brigade marched south off of Cemetery Ridge.

With Cross’ brigade pushing directly into Rose’s Wheat Field, Zook and Kelly pushed their brigades towards Stoney Hill, just north of the Wheat Field.  Awaiting the Irish Brigade was the 7th South Carolina, hidden by the trees on the hill.  Neither knew the other was there until the Irish Brigade reached the bottom of the hill.  The South Carolinians unleashed a volley of musketry, overshooting most of the Irishmen.  With their smooth bore muskets, the Irish Brigade was in a perfect position for some retribution.  Their first volley found its mark, followed by several other volleys that pushed the Rebels off the hill.  The 29th Massachusetts would follow the fleeing Confederates a short distance, before turning back.  Unfortunately, Irish Brigade at Gettysburgthe battle for the Wheat Field quickly turned against the Federals, with Zook and Cross being mortally wounded.  Pressed on both flanks, Caldwell determined he needed “to fall back or have my command taken prisoner.”(xxvi)

Sickles’ forward position crumbled.  Falling back to the Cemetery Ridge line, they would be out of action during the third day of Gettysburg.  Sickles himself, would be seriously wounded, near the Trostle Farm, and taken from the field on a stretcher.  Overnight, he would have his right leg amputated at a field hospital.  The Irish Brigade would again suffer.  Entering the battle at Stoney Hill, they would have approximately 530 troops.  They would end the day suffering nearly 200 casualties.  The Fighting 69th would suffer 25 casualties of the 75 men that received Corby’s absolution, just hours before.  The largest Irish Brigade regiment, the 29th Massachusetts, would endure 100 casualties out of 228 that went into battle – nearly 50%.  On the third day of battle, the brigade would be held in a reserve position, behind the II Corps on Cemetery Ridge.  The Federal Army of the Potomac won the battle of Gettysburg, but at a very high price, suffering over 22,000 casualties.  Lee’s plans to weaken the North’s will to continue fighting failed miserably, ending with his ragged retreat back to Virginia.

Over the coming winter months the 116th Pennsylvania was able to reach regimental strength, recruiting from as far away as Pittsburgh.  General Meagher again gave rousing speeches to fill the ranks of the 63d, 69th and 88th New York regiments.  Likewise, the 29th was able to recruit men to fill their ranks.  Many veterans, enticed by furloughs and bounties, would re-enlist when their three year terms expired.  In March 1864, Ulysses S. Grant was promoted lieutenant general, commanding all Federal ground forces.

In early May, Grant launched his Overland Campaign.  The Irish Brigade had a new commander, US Colonel Thomas Smyth.  Finally back up to full strength, the Irish Brigade would fight bravely with Hancock’s II Corps, during the Battle of the Wilderness.  Now part of US Major General Francis Barlow’s division, they would fight thirteen brigades of Lee’s army near the Brock Road, on the evening of May 6.  The Irish brigade, positioned in the woods 300 yards south of the Orange Plank Road, would fight bravely against CSA Brigadier General James Lane’s North Carolina brigade.  However, the pressure of the Confederate attack would finally push Hancock’s II Corps to the Brock Road, where they threw up rudimentary works in the evening.  Grant would sustain over 18,000 casualties during the battle of The Wilderness.  Fought to a draw, he would use the Brock Road, that Hancock’s Corps fought so bravely to hold, to push south in an attempt to turn Lee’s right flank.  Holding their position on May 8, the II Corps would serve as the rear guard for the Army of the Potomac.  The Irish Brigade would be one of the last to pull out, once again proving their fighting elan was second to none.  Hancock, recalling the fighting on the Orange Plank Road, stated that the “Irish Brigade behaved with great steadiness and gallantry.”(xxvii)

The II Corps would follow the Army of the Potomac to Spotsylvania Court House.  After the Wilderness, Grant had attempted to push around Robert E. Lee’s right flank.  J.E.B. Stuart’s Confederate Cavalry quickly engaged Grant’s lead elements before his entire army had vacated The Wilderness.  Lee quickly sent CSA Major General Richard Anderson’s 1st Corps (Anderson took over after Longstreet was seriously wounded at The Wilderness) to slow the progress of the Federal Army.  Reaching the area of Laurel Hill, just north Spotsylvania Court House, Anderson was able to engage US Major General Gouverneur Warren’s V Corps, on May 8.  With the II Corps acting as a rear guard, for the Army of the Potomac, they were attacked by CSA Major General William Mahone’s three brigade division along the Brock Road, at Todd’s Tavern.

II Corps at SpotsylvaniaBy the morning of May 9, Lee had entrenched his position north of Spotsylvania Court House.  The prominent feature of his line was a large salient, later dubbed the Mule Shoe, which was on his right flank.  From there his line extended west past Laurel Hill, ending on the Po River.  Grant’s line extended in an arc, from the Shady Grove Church Road, on his right, to the Ny River on his left.  Joining the Army of the Potomac, at Spotsylvania, was Ambrose Burnside’s IX Corps, which pushed down the Court House Road towards the east side of the Mule Shoe.  Hancock’s II Corps formed the right flank, followed by Warren’s V Corps, Sedgwick’s VI Corps and Burnside’s IX Corps on the left flank.  The Federal army would suffer the loss of VI Corps commander, John Sedgwick, on May 9.  Sedgwick would be the highest ranking Federal officer killed during the Civil War, when a sniper’s bullet instantly killed him.  US Brigadier General Horatio Wright, the senior division commander in the VI Corps, would take over corps command.

On the afternoon of May 10, CSA Major General Henry Heth’s 3d Corps division would attack Barlow’s Division, of the II Corps, below the Po River.  Grant had planned to attempt a flanking move on the Confederate left before he realized they had been flanked by Heth.  Prior to the engagement, Hancock had ordered Barlow to pull across the Po, as he recognized Barlow’s division was vulnerable to being defeated piecemeal while separated from the rest of the his II Corps.  While moving his division across the Po River, Heth slammed into the rear elements of his command.  His two right brigades, commanded by colonels Paul Frank and John Brooke, received the brunt of the attack, leaving many Federal casualties on the field controlled by Heth.  Smyth’s Irish Brigade, which had pulled back to the Po River, established a defensive position to allow the rest of the division to cross the river.  This position saved the division from destruction.  Colonel Nelson Miles’ brigade, on the division’s left flank, would be the last to cross as they were guarding against an assault by CSA Brigadier General William Mahone’s Division, across the Block House Bridge.  Meanwhile, further to their left, Warren’s V Corps was launching an attack against Laurel Hill.  Hancock would be ordered up, in support of Warren, but arrived too late to have a significant impact.  Warren’s attack was repulsed handily by CSA Major General Charles Fields’ 1st Corps division.  This attack was part of a larger simultaneous attack against the entire left side of the Mule Shoe Salient.  While Grant’s army wide attack was unsuccessful in penetrating the Confederate position, Grant had some success against the north tip of the salient.  This would weigh heavily on his upcoming battle plans.

On May 11, Grant ordered Hancock’s II Corps to march around Warren’s V Corps, and Wright’s VI Corps, and position itself in a position near the Landrum Farm.  After the marginal success against the north face of the Mule Shoe, on May 10, Grant believed a larger scale attack would offer a better chance for success.  The II Corps would lead this attack, ordered to take place at 4:30 a.m. on May 12.  Again, part of larger army wide attack, the V and VI Corps would assault the left side of the salient while Burnside’s IX Corps would attack from the right side of the salient.  Their attack was to commence once Hancock’s infantry engaged CSA Lieutenant General Richard Ewell’s 2d Corps.  At 4:30 a.m., on May 12, Hancock pushed his Corps forward.  Ordered to double quick across the open ground, they were to hold their fire until they reached the salient.  On the right flank of the forward attacking line were Brigadier General Gershom Mott’s Fourth Division and Major General David Birney’s Third Division, with Barlow’s Fourth Division, including the Irish Brigade, on the left flank.  Brigadier General John Gibbon’s Second Division would be in the reserve line – ordered to follow the forward line and support it where necessary.  Crossing the open ground, they encountered only sporadic fire as Confederate pickets raced back to their fortified line.  CSA Major General Edward “Allegheny” Johnson’s division held the unenviable position at the tip of the Mule Shoe Salient.  While most of his division were in position, muskets cocked, Hancock’s three lead divisions slammed into Johnson, catching them unprepared for such a large assault.  Barlow had compacted his lines, and had veered left, slamming into the salient head-on.  Smyth’s Irish Brigade would reach the salient first as the rest of the division was working their way through abatis the Confederates had placed for just such an emergency.  Private Henry Bell, of the 116th Pennsylvania, upon scaling the Confederate works yelled, “We run this machine now!”(xxviii)  With the onslaught of the II Corps, most of Johnson’s Division were captured, including Johnson who was captured by a private in the 29th Massachusetts.  The Federal attack, to this point, had been a success, with hundreds of prisoners captured and many Rebel flags taken.  As Birney’s last II Corps division entered the fray, they continued to push into the salient, through a gap nearly a half mile wide.  Unfortunately, they would run into a second Confederate line that was more prepared.  Receiving a heavy rain of artillery and musketry, their forward momentum faltered.

In an attempting a coordinated army wide assault, Burnside’s IX Corps pushed off with much enthusiasm.  Unfortunately, they would run into CSA Major General Cadmus Wilcox’s Division of Confederates.  This would slow Burnside’s corps to a crawl as they fought to take advantage of the opportunity Hancock’s II Corps success had created.  Meanwhile, around 7:30 a.m., portions of Wright’s VI Corps slammed into an area known as the Angle.  In their front were two of CSA Major General Robert Rodes’ brigades, commanded by brigadier generals Stephen D. Ramseur and Junius Daniel.  The fighting became chaotic, with hand-to-hand combat taking place along the Mule Shoe.  The musketry became so intense, that a large tree was literally cut in two.  A Federal soldier in Wright’s VI Corps aptly described the action at the Angle, “The battle was now at white heat.  There was one steady stream of iron and lead.  It seemed impossible that troops could stand such a severe fire.”(ixxx)

Late in the day, with darkness shrouding the battlefield, the true carnage of the day became apparent.  Men were strewn over the battlefield in contortive shapes, some alive, but many dead.  The fighting would continue long after the last light faded from the western sky.  All along the lines the struggle had turned to personal hand-to-hand combat, with clubbed muskets and bayonets the primary offensive tools.  Men having fallen wounded, in the trenches, would be trampled to death as other men came forward to take there place.  Through a continual rain, the trenches became a quagmire with the wounded soldiers pressed deeper into the mud.  After 3:00 a.m., on May 13, Robert E. Lee ordered his Army of Northern Virginia back to a new line, eliminating the salient, and creating a stronger defensive position.  In the morning, as the soldiers were waking up, their eyes took in the terror around them.  A Federal section of guns, within 100 yards of the Bloody Angle, stood motionless.  The horses were still hitched, but dead in the deep mud.  The team’s drivers were in their saddles, also dead.  A Federal officer summed of this ghastly scene, “The one exclamation of every man who looks on the spectacle is, ‘God forbid that I should ever gaze upon such a sight again.’”(xxx)  The Irish Brigade, along with the rest of both armies, would suffer terrible losses at Spotsylvania.  The most carnage occurred in the II and VI Corps, as they were involved in the melee around the Bloody Angle. 

The two opposing armies would hold their ground at Spotsylvania for nearly a week.  On May 18, the Irish Brigade would take part in a II Corps action against the new Rebel line.  Before 6:00 a.m., the II Corps would begin their attack on Richard Ewell’s 2d Corps.  Moving right up to the new Rebel fortifications, they would run into a wall of flame from the Confederate musketry.  They were essentially pinned to their positions, as to lift their heads over the works would be deadly.  After 2 1/2 hours, Meade called off the attack.  The retreating Federals would gather near the Landrum house, with the 69th New York and 116th Pennsylvania, of the Irish Brigade, left behind as pickets.  At 650, casualties in the II Corps were quite high for the short battle on May 18.  The majority of these casualties, 400, were in Barlow’s division, which included the Irish Brigade.(xxxi)

Starting on May 21, Meade began pulling his Army of the Potomac from the works at Spotsylvania.  Grant had ordered this move, pushing the army southeastward around Lee’s right flank.  Once again, Lee would anticipate this action and have his Army of Northern Virginia placed in an inverted “V” position, on the south bank of the North Anna River.  On May 23, the II Corps would be part of the Federal attacking force on Henagan’s Redoubt, which guarded Chesterfield Bridge over the North Anna River.  On May 24, the Federal army would use Chesterfield Bridge and Jericho Mills to cross the North Anna River.  There they would battle Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia.  The Irish Brigade would be involved in the fighting, attacking the right flank of Lee’s army, which was manned by Ewell’s 2d Corps.  With the Confederate flank refused, and a strong secondary line, their position was extremely defensible.  The Irish Brigade would be repulsed, with significant loss, by Ramseur’s Confederate brigade.  With daylight fading, Grant would realize the futility of attacking Lee’s entrenched line at the North Anna.  Executing one of his most brilliant disengagements, he would have his entire army pulled from their trenches by the morning on May 25.  Once again, Grant pushed south around Lee’s right flank hoping to catch the Confederates outside their field works.  For the next two days the Irish Brigade would tear up track on the Richmond and Fredericksburg Railroad, before pushing south to join the rest of the Army of the Potomac.

Starting on June 1, 1864, U.S. Grant would battle Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia at Cold Harbor.  Near the Gaines’ Mill battlefield, many of the veteran soldiers of the Irish Brigade recalled the ground over which they fought to extricate General Fitz John Porter’s V Corps, from its lone position, north of the Chickahominy River, in June 1862.  Two years later, they were back, within sight of Richmond, on what would be one of the bloodiest battlefields of the Civil War.  On June 2, the II Corps would arrive at Cold Harbor.  Placed on the right flank of the long Federal line, they Federal Assault at Cold Harborwould be repositioned over night so that on the morning of June 3, they would be holding the left flank of the army.  At 3:30 a.m., Barlow’s division was awakened in their protected position, in the trees, east of Dispatch Road.  The Irish Brigade was in a reserve position, in Brigadier General Francis Barlow’s II Corps Division, with the brigades of John Brooke and Nelson Miles leading the attack.  It was Grant’s plan, on June 3, to attack across his entire line, uncovering weak spots, and throwing his forces through them – ultimately rolling up Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia and uncovering the road to Richmond, Virginia.  At 4:30 a.m., the 10th Massachusetts Light Battery fired a shot, signaling the infantry to move forward.  The lead brigades stepped off, with Colonel Richard Byrne’s Irish Brigade moving behind Miles, and Brooke.  Their objective, 500 yards distant, was a salient in CSA Major General John C. Breckinridge’s line.  Barlow’s division quickly began to take casualties.  Breckinridge’s line included troops from Virginia and North Carolina: the 26th Virginia Battalion held the salient, with the 66th North Carolina on its left.  On its right, arrayed towards the south, were the 22d Virginia, 23d Virginia Battalion, 30th Virginia Battalion, 51st Virginia and 62d Virginia.  These regiments were supported by Caskie’s Maryland Battery, which opened on Barlow’s soldiers as soon as they were seen through the mist.  A member of the 66th North Carolina recalled the opening salvo of the day’s battle, “The fire ran down our lines from left to right like keys on a piano, and to the sharp crack of our rifles was added the roar of artillery as it joined them in the wild music of the hour – the carnival of death.”(xxxii)  Through this storm of lead, Miles’ brigade was able to capture a portion of the Confederate line at Edgar’s Salient.

Byrnes’ Irish Brigade advanced behind Miles’ mixed brigade of troops from Michigan, New Hampshire, New York and Pennsylvania.  While pushing forward, the Irish Brigade encountered a withering fire from CSA Brigadier General Gabriel C. Wharton’s Virginia regiments (30th Battalion, 51st and 62d).  Stopping in a cut near the Dispatch Road, the Irish Brigade had some cover as Miles continued to push forward.  Unfortunately, they still received significant infantry fire, from the Virginians, and enfilade fire from CSA Lieutenant Colonel William Pegram’s 3d Corps artillery.  The Irish Brigade would lose their commander when Richard Byrne was mortally wounded by a minie ball that had passed through Captain James D. Brady, of the 63d New York.(xxxii)  Senior regimental commander, Colonel Patrick Kelly, would take command after Byrne was killed.  CSA Brigadier General Joseph Finegan’s all Florida brigade would charge Barlow’s division, and the Confederates would recapture all of their line taken by Miles’ brigade.  The fight for Edgar’s Salient was brief, but very costly, especially for the Miles’ 7th New York Heavy Artillery and the 5th New Hampshire which penetrated the salient.  After being pushed back, by Finegan’s Brigade, the fighting on the Federal left flank sputtered out.  The results were no different along the entire Union line, with the attacking formations pushed back after suffering tremendous losses.  After June 3, Grant would take a defensive position at Cold Harbor.  Determining it would be a waste of life, with no chance of success, Grant determined to withdraw from Cold Harbor.  On June 12, Grant once again set his army in motion around Lee’s right flank.  On June 13, pushing across the James River on a 2,100 foot pontoon bridge (the longest ever constructed during the Civil War), Hancock’s II Corps would follow Warren’s V Corps, reaching the south bank of the James at 5:30 p.m.(xxxiv)

On June 15, US Major General William “Baldy” Smith’s XVIII Corps launched an attack against the small Confederate garrison at Petersburg, Virginia.  Commanding the fortifications was CSA General P.G.T. Beauregard.  He made good use of his 2,200 men, marching them back-and-forth, to appear much stronger than he was.  Grant believed the XVIII Corps could capture the garrison and move into Petersburg, disrupting the Southside Railroad – and the Confederate supplies it carried.  Smith, with roughly 16,000 men in his corps, was overly cautious and delayed the assault until 7 p.m.  Sending forth his skirmishers, he quickly pushed the Confederate back into their trenches.  Beauregard, knowing he was seriously out gunned, would pull his line back to Harrison Creek.  After his initial success, Smith would call off the attack until the next day.  On June 16, Grant, Meade and Hancock’s II Corps were south of the James.  Grant put Hancock in charge of an attacking force – the II Corps and two divisions of the IX Corps – and ordered them to attack.  Barlow’s Division, including the Irish Brigade, were to attack on the left.  The IX Corps divisions were to attack on the right.  Barlow pushed his division forward at 6:00 p.m.  Initially successful, they would capture two artillery positions before being repulsed.(xxxv)  The Irish Brigade would again suffer badly.  Colonel Patrick Kelly would be killed during the assault.  A member of the Irish Brigade summed it up well, “…strong old veteran soldiers wept like children, and wrung their hands in the frenzy….(the Irish Brigade) was a brigade no longer….(the only thing remaining was) the recollection of its services and suffering.”(xxxvi)  Over the coming weeks the brigade would work on building fortifications and their camps.

On June 22, the II Corps was in an advance position along the Jerusalem Plank Road.  They would be attacked there by CSA Brigadier General William Mahone’s Division.  Mahone violently attacked Barlow’s II Corps’ division, catching them by surprise and forcing them to fall back to the division’s trenches.  They would again battle on June 23, holding their advanced position.  All told, the Irish Brigade would suffer terribly in the initial offensive moves around Petersburg.  After their drubbing on June 22 the Irish Brigade was badly depleted.  The three New York regiments (63d, 69th and 88th) would be assigned to a consolidated brigade with six other New York regiments.  They would be commanded by Major Richard Maroney.  On July 28, this consolidated brigade would participate in the Second Battle of Deep Bottom, north of the James River.  Barlow would lead two divisions, including the Irish Brigade’s First Division, in an attack at Fussell’s Mill.  This attack drove away Confederate cavalry, but Barlow would be repulsed when CSA Brigadier General George “Tige” Anderson’s brigade arrived.  The fighting in this sector allowed the Federals to gain an advanced position north of the James River.

In August, the II Corps would move back south of the James.  U.S. Grant, never pleased with inaction, ordered Gouverneur Warren’s V Corps to secure a position along the Weldon Railroad, south of Petersburg.  Digging in at Globe Tavern, Warren was successful in gaining a good defensive position and was able to turn away attacks by General A.P. Hill’s 3d Corps, on August 18.  Warren would be reinforced by US Major General John Parke’s IX Corps (Burnside had been relieved of command), and would continue to fight for this key section of the Weldon Railroad, over the coming two days.  In an effort to relieve the growing pressure on Warren, Battle of Ream's StationGeorge Meade would send Hancock’s II Corps on a raid further south on the Weldon Railroad.  Reaching Ream’s Station, Hancock hastily erected field works.  On August 25, Federal cavalry under US Brigadier General David McM. Gregg would be pushed back towards Ream’s Station by CSA Major General Wade Hampton’s cavalry.  By 5:00 p.m., two divisions of Hill’s 3d Corps arrived on the field to supplement Hampton’s Cavalry.  Commanded by CSA Major Generals Henry Heth and William Mahone, these two divisions attacked the northern sector of Hancock’s lines, which contained the Irish Brigade.  Overwhelming two Federal regiments, Heth’s Division poured through the opening, scattering regiments and brigades.  With US Brigadier General Nelson Miles’ division (Miles had replaced Francis Barlow who was on leave) collapsing to the north, Hampton’s cavaliers pounded into US Major General John Gibbon’s division on the Federal left flank, causing many regiments to retreat  Many other soldiers would be captured.  Hancock was able to order a counterattack that would buy his corps enough time to withdraw to the Petersburg defenses.  Between Globe Tavern, and Second Ream’s Station, the Federals suffered nearly 7,000 casualties, of which nearly 5,000 were listed as missing, or captured.  While Ream’s Station was a sad defeat for the proud II Corps, Globe Tavern became a solid foothold for Grant, allowing him to continue extending his lines.

Over the coming months, Grant would continue to lengthen his lines and build fortifications.  He knew that he would win a war of attrition, as new recruits continued to come into his army, while Robert E. Lee was losing more to desertion than the few new recruits could offset.  The Irish Brigade also received recruits and were once again bouncing back.  On September 4, 1864, Father William Corby would conduct mass for the Irish Brigade, the third anniversary of the formation of the proud brigade.  Joining in the celebration was the 29th Massachusetts and special guest, Brigadier General Thomas Meagher.  Speaking to the assembled brigade, Meagher would commend the men, “Every battlefield, from Bull Run to Ream’s Station, but added another laurel to the wreath which the war would transfer for them to posterity.”(xxxvii)  On November 1, after the New York regiments were reinforced, General Miles ordered that the consolidated brigade be disbanded and the New York regiments be returned as the Second Brigade of the First Division.  Within a week, the 29th Massachusetts rejoined the Irish Brigade, once again restoring the original brigade structure.  Commanding the brigade was Colonel Robert Nugent, who had been with the 69th New York when it was still a militia unit.  Prior to the end of the Civil War Nugent would receive brevet promotion to brigadier general.

Over the next several months the Irish Brigade would not be engaged in any serious battles.  They would maintain a position in the trenches of Petersburg, and take part in normal camp life.  There was, however, the constant threat of being killed by a sniper, so soldiers were careful about keeping their heads down.  In the fall, with the three year term of enlistment expiring, those that had not re-enlisted as veterans were mustered out and returned north.  The brigade would receive new recruits to replace those who left.

On the night of October 29, 1864, the 69th New York was posted in trenches between the opposing forces.  Rebel soldiers would infiltrate the picket line on the left flank of the New Yorkers.  Rolling up the line, they would capture close to 170 men from the 69th, while the 111th New York, next in line, would lose almost 250 men.  It was an embarrassing time for the proud “Fighting 69th” but they would ultimately rebound.  In an after action investigation, Brigadier General Miles determined that many of the new recruits in the 69th New York had deserted from the lines, leaving it open to incursion by the Rebels.  A few of the deserters would be caught, suffering the ultimate punishment – execution.

On February 5, the Irish Brigade took part in an action to capture the fords over Hatcher’s Run.  These points were of strategic importance, as they secured passage for the Federal army to the west, and ultimately to the Southside Railroad.  Throwing up works to protect the crossing points, the Federals had secure access to points further west.  On March 17, the Irish Brigade would celebrate its last St. Patrick’s Day in the Army of the Potomac.  Farther Corby once again held a high mass for the Irishmen, followed by the traditional “steeple chase” and “flat race.”  Attended by Army of the Potomac commander, George Meade, and a dozen other corps and division commanders, it was a welcome respite to life in the trenches.  Unfortunately, Second Lieutenant Michael McConville, of the 69th New York, after surviving nearly four years of combat, would be thrown form his horse, suffering a fractured skull.  He would die little more than a week later - another casualty of the fratricidal war between the states.(xxviii)

On March 25, the Confederacy taking one of its final gasps, launched an assault on Fort Stedman.  While the II Corps were not active in this operation, the Rebels were able to capture the fort, holding it temporarily until a sledgehammer assault by the Union forces pushed them back to their own lines.  This would be the last major offensive action by Robert E. Lee’s proud Army of Northern Virginia.  While this action was taking place, near the center of the lines, Meade ordered the Irish Brigade and portions of the II Corps to advance from their Hatcher’s Run defenses and push towards Skinner’s Farm, where they would have a stand-up fight for several hours.  The Irish Brigade once again demonstrated their elan, “(with a) splendid spectacle of unflinching bravery.”  The 69th’s Captain John D. Mulhall, who had just returned to duty from a Cold Harbor wound, while leading his men in a oblique movement, to blunt an assault on his flank, was struck by a minie ball in his leg.  He would lay on the field for several hours before receiving medical care.  The 29th Massachusetts, with only enough men to fill five companies, would run out of ammunition. They would suffer terribly, with their regimental commander, Lieutenant Colonel James Flemming, suffering a wound to his shoulder.(xxxix)

On March 29, the II Corps, with the famed Irish Brigade, were pushed to the offensive again.  With Major General Philip Sheridan in overall command, the detached unit began a push around the Confederates’ right flank, once again trying to take command of their supply line.  Due to a misunderstanding of orders, the II Corps would not participate in Sheridan’s victory over CSA Major General George Pickett’s forces at Five Forks, on April 1.  However, they would be heavily engaged in the fighting at Sutherland’s Station on April 2 – the same day that Robert E. Lee vacated the trenches surrounding Petersburg and Richmond.  The II Corps, now commanded by US Major General Andrew A. Humphreys, would attack CSA Major General Henry Heth’s entrenchments, running from Hatcher’s Run to White Oak Road.  What they found were abandoned trenches.  With Humphreys receiving Robert E. Lee Surrenders at Appomattoxorders to turn towards Petersburg, Nelson Miles’ division, including the Irish Brigade, pushed after Heth’s retreating column.  They would find them behind entrenchments at Sutherland’s Station, on the Southside Railroad.  Miles launched his assault at 12:30 p.m. and would suffer several repulses before he would send for reinforcements.  Humphreys, in an effort to support Miles, would turn his division around.  Miles determined to push Heth aside, would attack a third time.  The Irish Brigade, supported by US Colonel John Ramsey’s Fourth Brigade, would launch a frontal assault on the Confederate lines, after Captain A. Judson Clark’s Battery B, 1st New Jersey Light Artillery, opened a withering fire on Rebel defenses.  Heth’s line finally crumbled and began a retreat.  The victorious Union troops quickly pushed after Heth, capturing over 1,000 prisoners.(xl)  During the fighting at Sutherland’s Station, the Irish Brigade would suffer another 130 casualties – but they recognized that this would be their last campaign and continued to push forward.  Humphrey’s II Corps would arrive at Appomattox Court House on April 9.  Ordering his men into battle lines, he would learn at 4:00 p.m. that General Robert E. Lee had surrendered his proud Army of Northern Virginia to Ulysses S. Grant.

The last formal action of the Irish Brigade was participating in the Grand Review in Washington City, on May 22, 1865.  By then Abraham Lincoln had been assassinated and President Andrew Johnson sat next to Ulysses S. Grant on the reviewing stand.  At 2:00 p.m., Colonel Robert Nugent, on his black horse, marched his proud brigade past the stand.  Besides their green battle flags, each member of the brigade had a sprig of boxwood in their hats, identifying them as proud members of the Irish Brigade.

On June 25, 1865, the 63d, 69th and 88th New York regiments returned to New York to be mustered out of Federal service.  They would be escorted through New York City on July 4 – Independence Day.  The Irish Brigade’s 700 men were aptly described in an article in the Irish American, “…every one of whom looked strong and hearty; their faces, bronzed by the exposures of the field were, along the march, wreathed with smiles, as cheer after cheer rent the air, welcoming them back to citizenship and their former homes.”(xli)  The 29th Massachusetts would be mustered out of Federal service on June 29, while the 116th Pennsylvania would muster out on July 14.  They would each receive warm welcomes as they returned home.

The Civil War was a fight between brothers, cousins, fathers and sons.  Its tolls were especially harsh on many families – but none as much as the famed Irish Brigade, and its flagship regiment the “Fighting 69th.”  Below is a regimental breakdown of the casualties the brigade endured.

63d New York = 249 (killed, wounded, missing or dying of illness)
69th New York = 401 (killed, wounded, missing or dying of illness)
88th New York = 223 (killed, wounded, missing or dying of illness)
29th Massachusetts = 387 (killed, wounded, missing or dying of illness)
116th Pennsylvania = 234 (killed, wounded, missing or dying of illness)

Total brigade casualties were an astounding 1,494.(xlii)

Irish Brigade Commanders

Michael Corcoran
Colonel Michael Corcoran
Born: September 21, 1827
Place of Birth: County Sligo, Ireland
Death: December 22, 1863
Place of Death: Suffolk, Virginia

Thomas F. Meagher
Brigadier General Thomas Francis Meagher
Born: August 3, 1823
Place of Birth: Waterford, Ireland
Death: July 1, 1867
Place of Death: Missouri River, Montana Territory

Thomas A Smyth
Major General Thomas A. Smyth
Born: December 25, 1832
Place of Birth: County Cork, Ireland
Death: April 9, 1865
Place of Death: Farmville, Virginia

Richard Byrnes
Colonel Richard Byrne
Born: 1832
Place of Birth: County Cavan, Ireland
Death: June 10, 1864
Place of Death: Cold Harbor, Virginia

Patrick Kelly
Colonel Patrick Kelly
Born: 1822
Place of Birth: County Galway, Ireland
Death: June 14, 1864
Place of Death: Petersburg, Virginia

Robert Nugent
Brigadier General Robert Nugent
Born: June 27, 1824
Place of Birth: Kilkeel County Down, Ireland
Death: June 20, 1901
Place of Death: Brooklyn, New York 

Additional Resources
Maps of Significant Battles of the Irish Brigade*

Siege of Yorktown
Seven Pines (Fair Oaks)
Gaines’ Mill
Glendale (Frayser’s Farm)
Malvern Hill
Antietam
Fredericksburg
Chancellorsville
Gettysburg
The Wilderness
First Deep Bottom
Second Deep Bottom
Second Battle of Ream’s Station
Hatcher’s Run
White Oak Road

* These maps are used courtesy of the Civil War Preservation Trust – Please support their efforts by becoming a member.

(i) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 119.
(ii) Gottfried, Bradley M., The Maps of First Bull Run, published by Savas Beatie, LLC in 2009, Pg. 2.
(iii) Eicher, David J., The Longest Night, published by Simon & Schuster, September 2001, Pg. 79.
(iv) Gottfried, Bradley M., The Maps of First Bull Run, published by Savas Beatie, LLC in 2009, Pg. 22.
(v) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pgs. 15–17.
(vi) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 17.
(vii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 22.
(viii) The
Civil War Soldiers and Sailors System was used to research this article.
(ix) Warner, Ezra J., Generals In Blue: Lives of the Union Commanders, published by the Louisiana State Press in 1999, Pgs. 317–318.
(x) Sears, Stephen W., To The Gates of Richmond: The Peninsula Campaign, published by Ticknor & Fields in 1992, Pg. 8.
(xi) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 39.
(xii) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 147.
(xiii) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 149.
(xiv) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 42.
(xv) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 45.
(xvi) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 159.
(xvii) Sears, Stephen W., Landscape Turned Red: The Battle of Antietam, published by Ticknor & Fields in 1983, Pg. 243.
(xviii) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 164.
(ixx) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 166.
(xx) Battle of Fredericksburg, at
Wikipedia.
(xxi) Rable, George C., Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg!, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2002, Pg. 222.
(xxii) Rable, George C., Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg!, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2002, Pg. 226.
(xxiii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pgs. 66–67.
(xxiv) Wylie, Paul R., The Irish General: Thomas Francis Meagher, published by The University of Oklahoma Press in 2007, Pg. 178.
(xxv) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 87.
(xxvi) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pgs. 90–91.
(xxvii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 105.
(xxviii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 106.
(ixxx) Rhea, Gordon C., The Battles for Spotsylvania Court House and the Road to Yellow Tavern, May 7–12, 1864, published by Louisiana State Press in 1997, Pg. 279.
(xxx) Rhea, Gordon C., The Battles for Spotsylvania Court House and the Road to Yellow Tavern, May 7–12, 1864, published by Louisiana State Press in 1997, Pg. 308.
(xxxi) Rhea, Gordon C., To the North Anna River: Grant and Lee, May 13–25, 1865, published by Louisiana State Press in 2000, Pg. 154.
(xxxii) Rhea, Gordon C., Cold Harbor: Grant and Lee, May 26–June 3, 1864, published by the Louisiana State University Press in 2002, Pg. 322.
(xxxiii) Rhea, Gordon C., Cold Harbor: Grant and Lee, May 26–June 3, 1864, published by the Louisiana State University Press in 2002, Pg. 328.
(xxxiv) Jordan, David M., Winfield Scott Hancock: A Soldier’s Life, published by Indiana University Press in 1995, Pg. 141.
(xxxv) Hess, Earl J., In the Trenches at Petersburg: Field Fortifications and Confederate Defeat, published by the University of North Carolina Press in 2009, Pg. 24.
(xxxvi) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 114.
(xxxvii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 119.
(xxxviii) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 123.
(xxxix) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pgs. 123–124.
(xl) Greene, A. Wilson, The Final Battles of the Petersburg Campaign: Breaking the Backbone of the Rebellion, published by The University of Tennessee Press in 2008, Pg. 327.
(xli) Bilby, Joseph G., The Irish Brigade in the Civil War: The 69th New York and Other Irish Regiments of the Army of the Potomac, published by Da Capo Press in 1997, Pg. 127.
(xlii) The Civil War Soldiers and Sailors System was used to research this article.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +4 (from 4 votes)

Aug
19
2009
0

Announcement from CWPT on Wilderness Wal-Mart Hearing

Today, I received an email from the Civil War Preservation Trust regarding upcoming public hearings on the proposed Wal-Mart Supercenter adjacent to the battlefield.  This is the last opportunity for public input.  Please review the email below for more information.

********************************************************
 From the Civil War Preservation Trust – August 19, 2009

Final Public Hearings on Wilderness Walmart August 20 and 24

As you may have already heard, the final public hearings on the Wilderness Walmart proposal have now been rescheduled for Thursday, August 20, and Monday, August 24. 

These hearings represent the last opportunity to tell Orange County that the Wilderness Battlefield is no place for big box sprawl.  If you live within driving distance of Orange County, please attend the hearings and urge the county to find another location for Walmart’s superstore away from this hallowed battleground.

Planning Commission: August 20 at 7:00 p.m.
Board of Supervisors: August 24 at 6:00 p.m.


CWPT will have an information table set-up one hour before the hearings, and we encourage all who attend to arrive early.  Both public hearings will be held in the Orange County High School Auditorium, 201 Selma Road, Orange, Va.  Click here for directions and a map of the school.

 If you have not already done so, there is also still time to send a letter to Walmart CEO Michael Duke encouraging the company to select an alternate location in Orange County for the proposed store.  Let Walmart know in the strongest possible terms that the Wilderness Battlefield is no place for a superstore.

I hope we can count on your continued support in this fight to protect the Wilderness Battlefield.  If you have any questions about the upcoming hearings please feel free to contact me personally at 202-367-1861 ext. 7220.

Thank you,
Brent Laurenz

P.S.  For the latest information on the hearings, please visit CWPT’s Wilderness Walmart homepage.

www.civilwar.org

**************************************************************

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Aug
19
2009
0

An Update on the Wilderness Wal-Mart

Friend, and fellow blogger, Eric Wittenberg posted an update on the Wilderness Wal-Mart yesterday.  Check it out on his blog, Rantings of a Civil War Historian.  Get involved with the Civil War Preservation Trust and help save the Wilderness Battlefield!

Here is a link to Eric’s article: More on the Wilderness Wal-Mart.

Thanks for supporting our Civil War battlefields – part of our Country’s heritage!

Mike Noirot

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (1 vote cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)

Aug
15
2009
0

Kentucky Battlefield Wanderings

This past week I was in Louisville for work. After meetings on Wednesday and Thursday, I had the opportunity to visit two wonderful battlefields: Mill Springs (also called Logan’s Crossroads and Fishing Creek) on Thursday, and Perryville on Friday. I really enjoy Kentucky battlefields. The state does a wonderful job protecting and maintaining their Civil War history. Additional kudos to the Civil War Preservation Trust which has saved many acres of Kentucky battlefields.

Watch for a full length essay on the Battle of Perryville, in October, around the battle’s anniversary on October 8. I was able to take some amazing sunrise pictures that I will unveil at that time.

Lastly, as yesterday was a vacation day, I stopped at two distilleries on Kentucky’s Bourbon Trail. One of them was the Four Roses Distillery. There will be a very interesting blog article, about this distillery, in the coming weeks. Obviously there is a connection between it and the Civil War.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 4.2/5 (5 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Aug
10
2009
0

Wilson’s Creek -the Civil War breaks out in the West

Totten's battery position on Bloody HillToday marks the 148th anniversary of the Battle of Wilson’s Creek.  During the spring, and summer, of 1861, the Lincoln administration was very concerned with keeping the border states in the Union.  These states were slave states that had not seceded from the United States and were part of the upper south.  They included Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky and Missouri.  Missouri had chosen to not follow her sister slave states out of the Union, but the state had many significant pockets of “secesh.”  During this same period Lincoln was working diligently to staff his growing volunteer army with capable general officers.  At the start of 1861, there were 1,105 officers in the regular army.  Of these, 824 were West Point graduates, the majority of which were lieutenants and captains.  From this number, 296 had already resigned from the regular army, most of which had chosen to pursue careers in the private sector or not fight in the war.  184 had resigned to receive commissions in the Confederate Provisional Army.  Lincoln was left with left with 754 West Point educated officers to man his rapidly growing army.(i)  These officers would fill ranks from lieutenants to major generals.  Another consideration, as Lincoln was working to add general officers was political.  He needed to keep the Radical Republicans and War Democrats well represented.  The War Democrats were very important as most of them would come from the border states.  Lastly, Lincoln was concerned with having an ethnic balance in his general officer ranks.  German and Irish immigrants topped his list of preferred ethnicities.

Even before the Confederates fired on Fort Sumter, Lincoln had his hands full in Missouri.  It was a sharply divided state that had a Confederate supporting militia – the Missouri State Guard – and extensive guerilla activities occurring throughout the state by Partisan Rangers.  To stabilize Nathanial Lyonthe St. Louis area, US Brigadier General Nathanial Lyon, with an ethnic blend of local militia, primarily of German descent, marched on Camp Jackson, in St. Louis, on the morning of May 10, 1861.  The Confederate militia general, D.M. Frost, facing a vastly larger force surrendered Camp Jackson.  Without a space to house the Confederate militia, Lyon determined to parole them, after they took an oath of allegiance to the United States.  However, instead of immediately releasing the Southern militia he decided to humiliate them by marching them through the streets of St. Louis.  This proved disastrous as Southern supporting civilians had begun throwing rocks, bottles and eventually fired guns into Lyon’s soldiers.  Before the melee was over, 28 civilians had been killed and 75 wounded.  Four soldiers were also killed.(ii)  While a debacle, the capture of Camp Jackson solidified the Federal government’s control on St. Louis the majority of eastern Missouri.

Franz SigelBy early July, the majority of the fighting in Missouri had shifted to the southwestern portion of the state.  By this time, John C. Fremont had been appointed major general in the regular army, the third highest ranking general in the United States.  On July 3, 1861 he was officially appointed to command the Western Department – encompassing all of Illinois and all states west of the Mississippi River.  Assigned to his department was Nathanial Lyon and US Colonel Franz Sigel.  Sigel represented an important ethnic group for Lincoln.  Sigel received his military training in Germany and would fight with the revolutionary forces in Germany, against Prussia, rising to the rank of general.  After immigrating to the United States, in the 1840’s, Sigel would relocate to St. Louis and be very involved in the German community.  This appealed to Lincoln as he need the support of German Americans.(iii)

In early July, Sigel would push west from Springfield, Missouri, searching for the Confederate army.  He would find them north of Carthage.  With his 1000 man army camped at Carthage, he would be induced to attack 4,000 Confederates, in battle line, 10 miles north of Carthage, on July 5.  Sigel would be guilty of not scouting the terrain well enough, and would be attacked on the flanks, before he would be forced to retire.  The first major battle in Missouri, the Battle of Carthage, would end with a Confederate victory.

With Sigel defeated, General Nathanial Lyon would rush towards Springfield, Missouri to keep Sigel from being torn apart.  Reunited with Sigel, Lyon found himself at the end of a precarious supply line, that used a railroad from St. Louis to Rolla, and wagons from Rolla to Springfield.  While Fremont had still not arrived in St. Louis (he would not arrive until July 25), he issued clear orders to Lyon stating if his army “was not strong enough to maintain his position as far in advance as Springfield, he should fall back toward Rolla until reinforcements should meet him.”(iv)  Unfortunately, Lyon would not receive these orders until three days after they were written by which time the strategic situation in southwest Missouri had changed.

Sterling PriceLyon was now facing a significant army of Missouri State Guard, commanded by CSA Major General Sterling Price, and the Confederate Western Army, commanded by CSA Brigadier General Ben McCullough.  By August 1, Lyon’s Army of the West would be bivouacked south of Springfield, near the Ray Farm.  Southwest of his position was the highest ground in the area.  This hill would earn the moniker, Bloody Hill, during the coming battle.  Over the coming days, Lyon would receive reports of a growing Confederate presence to his south, and southwest.  Captured Rebel soldiers provided intelligence that McCullough’s forces numbered close to 15,000, many of them cavalry that could flank Lyon’s position.  Additionally the Missouri State Guard was somewhere to the southwest.  With only a light garrison at Springfield, Lyon would call a council of war on August 3.  With almost no food to feed his army, and a tenuous supply line, Lyon determined to pull back north to Springfield.  William Branson of the 1st Iowa Infantry vividly described the situation, “General Lyon has come to the wise conclusion that it is all foolishness to march his men any further south, as he is killing more men every day marching them through the hot sun than by bullets.”(v)  On the morning of August 4, Lyon would relocate his army to Springfield.  On August 5, Lyon received bad news from St. Louis.  Fremont, finally at his headquarters, had answered previous dispatches from Lyon requesting more troops.  There would be none sent.  Pulling back to Rolla would be the most prudent choice, but Lyon was determined to push the Confederate forces from Missouri.

Ben McCulloughThe situation on the Confederate side was not much better.  Price and McCullough had been openly clashing.  After a small skirmish at Dug Springs, on August 2, McCullough began to question the bravery of the troops in Price’s Missouri State Guard.  Additionally, he was unsure of Price’s ability to command effectively.  On August 4, the relationship nearly ruptured between the two commanders when Price learned that McCullough was considering a retreat to Arkansas.  Price would ride to McCullough’s headquarters and issue an ultimatum, “…if you will consent to help us whip Lyon and to repossess Missouri, I will put myself and all my forces under your command, and will obey you as faithfully as the humblest of your men….if you refuse to accept this offer, I will move with the Missourians alone, against Lyon.”(vi)  While some of this dialog may be questioned, there is no doubt that there was at least a compromise between the two officers.  McCullough would issue orders to move towards Wilson’s Creek and engage the enemy, on August 5.  Moving out as planned, Price found the Federal camps abandoned and advised McCullough that the enemy was in full retreat.  Over the coming days, the Confederate army would move their camps to the area of Wilson’s Creek – for the primary reason that the creek offered a source of good drinking water.  Starting on August 7, he would use his cavalry to determine the Federal position and strength.  McCullough determined that he would push after them and strike them in the rear.

On the Federal side, Lyon’s forces back in Springfield, would receive supplies on August 6.  This allowed the men to get their fill of food, and rest.  With the improved supply line, and his commanders’ desire to not give up southwest Missouri without a fight, Lyon’s confidence began to increase.  By this time, the Federal commander also knew that the Confederates had set up camp at Wilson’s Creek.  On August 8, Lyon met with his officers for a council of war.  He asked them, “Shall we endeavor to retreat without giving the enemy battle beforehand and run the risk of having to fight every inch along our line of retreat?  Or shall we attack him in his position and endeavor to hurt him so he cannot follow?”(vii)  Lyon, always aggressive, favored the latter option.  Sigel offered another option, suggesting that Lyon split his force, with Sigel taking the smaller portion and moving around the Confederate right flank, he would attack them from the south, while Lyon would move and attack them from the north – catching them in a pincer.  On the afternoon of August 9, Lyon would call another council of war.  Turning the meeting over to Sigel, the German explained his plan for his proposed flank attack.  The officers in attendance voiced their concerns immediately, with the biggest concern being that the size of Sigel’s flanking column was too small to be of use.  Lyon sustained Sigel and overrode their concerns.  They would attack McCullough, hurting him badly enough that he could not pursue them when they pulled back to Rolla.  He issued orders for the Federal Army of the West to begin their march at 6:00 p.m. that evening.  The plans were now set for the first major battle in the Western Theater.

Sigel began his march on the evening of August 9.  Leaving Springfield with Company I 1st U.S. Cavalry, Company C 2d U.S. Dragoons, 3d and 5th Missouri Infantry and Franz Backof’s six gun battery of the Missouri Light Artillery he had an effective strength of 1,200.  He would march east of Wilson’s Creek, to a position south of the Confederate camps, before pushing west across the creek and attacking from the south.  Lyon would lead his remaining three brigades, with batteries containing ten guns, south from Springfield.  He planned to avoid the Wire Road, the route the Confederates would expect an attack from, and push cross country from due north.

At 5:00 a.m. on August 10, Lyon arrived on the north spur of Bloody Hill.  Immediately ordering a battery of his guns to fire a volley, it signaled the army to attack.  Immediately in their front was James Cawthorn’s Missouri State Guard Cavalry – 1,200 strong.  Leading the Federal infantry assault was the 2d Kansas, 1st Missouri, 1st Kansas, 1st Iowa and a battalion of the 1st U.S. Infantry.  The Missouri infantry regiment, near the center of the line, would encounter the most resistance from Cawthorn’s cavalry.  However, with their lines significantly overlapped, the the Rebel cavalry had Bloody Hill from the Confederate Positionno choice but to fall back.  Reaching the top of Bloody Hill, and surveying the Rebel camps, Lyon was confident, “In less than an hour they’ll wish they were a thousand miles away.”(vii)

Before dawn, Sterling Price sent his adjutant, Captain Thomas Snead, to McCullough’s headquarters.  He wanted additional information on the plans to attack Lyon at Springfield.  The Confederates were totally unprepared for what was about to happen.  McCullogh, having decided to speak directly to Price, after his conference with Snead, rode the short distance to Price’s headquarters at William Edwards’ farm.  Sitting down to have breakfast with Price, they were soon interrupted by John Snyder, from Colonel Rives’ Missouri State Guard cavalry stating that the Federals were “approaching with twenty thousand men and 100 pieces of artillery.”(viii)  With heavy skirmishing and artillery fire taking place directly to their north, both Price and McCullough were fooled by a physical anomaly caused by terrain and weather conditions: an acoustic shadow.  This acoustic shadow prevented them from hearing the sounds of battle, no more than 3/4 of a mile distant.  Sterling Price's headquarters at the Edwards' FarmWhile not twenty thousand men, Lyon’s 3,900 men were about to surprise Rive’s First Cavalry regiment.  Coming over the crest of Bloody Hill, were the 1st Missouri and 1st Kansas Infantry regiments.  Additionally Captain James Totten’s six gun battery of Company F, 2d U.S. Artillery quickly unlimbered and joined the infantry in blasting away at Rive’s cavalry.  Rive would later describe the incoming fire as, “a tremendous shower of case-shot, grape and minie ball.”  Luckily enough for Rive, the Federal aim was not perfect and much of the incoming lead missed its mark.  This would give him time to split his cavalry into two columns and escape by each flank.  They would not reunite until late in the day, after the battle was over.  CSA Lieutenant Colonel A.J. Austin and two privates were were killed in the action that morning.(ix)

Approximate 1/3 of a mile to the east, on another hill, was the Winn house.  Having set up his headquarters there, McCullough also had Captain William E. Woodruff’s four gun Pulaski Light Artillery Battery nearby.  Woodruff witnessed what was taking place on Bloody Hill, as Cawthorn’s Missouri State Guard Cavalry were rapidly descending the hill.  While not too alarmed at this point, as McCullough’s forces doubted the elan of the state militia, The Pulaski Battery placementthat soon changed when he saw Totten’s battery unlimber and start firing into the retreating cavaliers.  Quickly unlimbering his four gun section, Woodruff brought them into battery.  Spotted by the Federal artillery, on Bloody Hill, they quickly positioned their guns and began firing into Woodruff’s men.  Fortunately the Federal fire was high.  Woodruff was able to get the range correct and began pouring a fire into Lyon’s forces on Bloody Hill.  This would hold the Union forces on the hill, buying much needed time for McCullough’s Confederate Western Army and Price’s Missouri State Guard.  It would take Lyon until 6:30 a.m. to bring his brigades into position, by which time Price’s State Guard, bivouacked closest to Bloody Hill, was able to get their lines in some order to accept battle.  Simultaneously, McCullough was getting his men in line, on the east side of Wilson’s Creek – just south of the John Ray farmhouse.

As McCullough was organizing his line, US Captain Joseph B. Plummer was pushing his three company battalion, of the 1st U.S. Infantry across Wilson’s Creek.  He had been ordered to detach from the main Federal line, North edge of Ray's cornfieldby Lyon, and push the Confederate right flank.  He would cross the creek just south of John Gibson’s Mill.  The Gibson family took cover in their home while Plummer’s Regulars pushed through their property, to the north end of John Ray’s cornfield.  Seeing Woodruff’s Pulaski Artillery pounding Lyon’s forces on Bloody Hill, Plummer determined to storm the artillery.  McCullough, about this time learned that his forces south of the Missouri State Guard had been attacked from the south.  Franz Sigel’s brigade had entered the fight, primarily against Confederate cavalry, at the south end of Joseph Sharp’s cornfield.  Pushing them through the cornfield, Sigel’s small brigade was able to cross the Wire Road and approach the camps of McCullough’s regulars – where confusion reigned.  Most of the Confederate soldiers were quietly enjoying breakfast and had not heard the firing on Bloody Hill, due to the acoustic shadow. 

Farther north, close to the Ray home, CSA Colonel Louis Hebert got his men in order along the Wire Road.  His 3d Louisiana Infantry and CSA Colonel Dandridge McRae’s Arkansas Battalion began to push north, up the Wire Road.  CSA Colonel James McIntosh’s 2d Arkansas Mounted Rifles, under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Benjamin T. Embry (McIntosh was at this The Ray Housetime acting as McCullough’s adjutant) quickly passed around Hebert and McRae’s infantry and pushed towards the Ray cornfield.  The combined Rebel infantry and cavalry passed near the Pulaski Battery, which was under heavy artillery fire from Bloody Hill.  Reaching a shallow area near the Ray spring house, they were able to organize their men before pushing up the hill to the cornfield.  As they came up the hill, they were surprised to see Plummer’s Regular U.S. Infantry on the other side of a fence, bordering the field.  Two companies of Hebert’s 3d Louisiana were able to deploy and push towards the Federals who were also surprised to see so many of the enemy within 15 paces of their position.  Both sides gathered on opposite sides of the fence, with many of the U.S. Regulars kneeling for cover.  Due to tall weeds, and the fence row, Plummer’s troops were immediately at a disadvantage, “men frequently asked, ‘Where are they?’ ‘What do you see?’”(x)  This bought Hebert time to bring his detachment into proper position, from which point they started to fire.  Instructed to fire “low,” the musketry took down many Federal soldiers.  Because of the length of his line, Hebert’s forces were able to pour an enfilade fire down Plummer’s left flank.  Plummer, pacing behind the lines, encouraged his men, “Keep cool, my boys, you are doing well, you are mowing them down.”  His enthusiasm had the proper effect and allowed the Regulars to maintain their position while suffering through a hail of lead.  Hebert’s right flank, reaching far past the left flank of the Federals, began to swing around, on their left, forming a 90 degree angle.  They would suffer miserably during this move, with, “(men) dropping all along the line; it was becoming uncomfortably hot.”(ix)  Plummer’s Regulars, by this time, were outnumbered three-to-one.  McIntosh, having arrived, ordered a charge.  While elements of McRae’s Arkansas Battalion did not receive, or understand the orders, the Federals were overwhelmed by the charge and retreated north, across the cornfield,The fence line at Ray's cornfield in an organized fashion.  By now, disorganized by their success, the Rebel troops stormed north after the retreating U.S. Regulars.  Pausing to reorganize their lines, they threatened to flank Lyon’s main force on the other side of Wilson’s Creek.  Seeing the failing position on their left, US Lieutenant John Du Bois brought his battery into action.  Posted on Bloody Hill, to support Totten’s Battery, he immediately began raking Hebert’s Confederates while they chased after Plummer’s soldiers.  Du Bois who had believed, “the day lost,” would prove instrumental in holding the Rebels in position, allowing the Regulars to escape across the creek.  While only a few men became casualties, the heavy artillery fire had a dramatic effect on the men.  CSA Sergeant William Watson described the fire as “a storm of shrapnel and grape.”(xii)  Hebert immediately ordered a retreat to the woods, south of their position.  During the fighting at the Ray cornfield Hebert’s detachment lost about 100 men.  Plummer would suffer significantly worse, with 90 casualties – nearly 30% of his original strength.

On the other end of the battlefield, Franz Sigel’s small brigade reached their gathering point, a tall ridge east of Wilson’s Creek, before 5:30 a.m.  Hearing Lyon’s artillery fire, from the north, he dressed his lines and prepared to attack.  Sigel then ordered the “green” 1st Missouri Light Franz Sigel's first positionArtillery to fire towards the Confederate camps.  Unfortunately, for Sigel, this announced to the opposing forces his presence south of their position.  With shells screeching through the tree tops, McCullough’s Confederates prepared for the attack.  The following cavalry regiments got into line: 1st Arkansas Mounted Rifles, the 2d Kansas-Texas Cavalry, 1st Arkansas Cavalry, James P. Major’s Missouri State Cavalry and William Brown’s Missouri State Cavalry.  CSA Colonel Elkanah Greer’s mixed Kansas-Texas cavalry sported a company, Texas Hunters, that had Colt’s repeating rifles.  These guns were highly effective.  Captain Thomas Winston, commander of the Texas Hunters, wanted to use the company to anchor the Confederate formation.  Unfortunately, it was very difficult for these men to coordinate their lines, under the heavy fire Franz Backof’s Missouri Light Artillery were firing into the camp.  The Rebel cavalry panicked, pushing north along the Wire Road towards the ford on Wilson’s Creek.  Caught up in their baggage trains, and the Missouri State Guard Cavalry, the 2d South Kansas-Texas Cavalry ended up becoming separated – with one company crossing the creek, while the other two companies pushed north towards Bloody Hill.  With the melee that resulted, Sigel’s initial bombardment threw the entire Confederate cavalry into confusion.  Some heading towards Bloody Hill while others pushed across the ford of Wilson’s Creek.  These units would operate independently, attempting to protect individual batteries, and infantry units, throughout the coming battle.

Seeing the Confederate cavalry reeling, Sigel left four of Backof’s guns on the ridge, overlooking the creek, and pushed his 2d U.S. Dragoons, 1st Cavalry units and the 3d and 5th Missouri Infantry regiments across Wilson’s Creek, to the John Dixon farm.  While Backof’s guns continued to pound the enemy, US Captain Eugene Carr dismounted his 1st U.S. Cavalry company, Franz Backof's Missouri Light Artillery Battery positionwith one men holding four horses, the other men acted in an infantry fashion, firing their carbines into the retreating Confederate forces.  Carr would continue to push north, over 1/2 mile from Sigel’s line, and nearly to the Rebel camps.  From this position he was shocked to see McCullough’s men reforming in line of battle – in the exact area that Sigel was marching the rest of his brigade.  If the opposing sides continued to march in the same direction, the Confederates would fall on Sigel’s left flank.  Sigel, stopped at this point, and issued orders for the remainder of Backof’s guns, still on the ridge behind them, to limber up and join the rest of his brigade.  Marching north on the Wire Road, Sigel maintained his brigade in column – the most efficient method of moving troops.  Unfortunately he was unaware of the potential threat on his left, as he was monitoring the Confederates to his right, along Wilson’s Creek.  From 6:30 to 7:00 a.m., Sigel rested his troops.  Once the remainder of Backof’s guns reached the field, Sigel resumed offensive operations.  Placing them along the Wire Road, Sigel ordered Backof to open on the enemy.  The artillery once again unnerved the Rebels as they sheltered in the woods.  Pushing his brigade north on the Wire Road, they arrived at the Sharp home.  By then, the Confederate cavalry had pushed east across Wilson’s Creek and the field was clear of the enemy.  Interestingly enough, the reforming Confederate line that Carr witnessed, north of Sigel’s position, never joined the fray.

While Plummer was being attacked, in Ray’s cornfield, and Sigel was attacking the Confederate southern flank, the situation on Bloody Hill was rapidly developing.  General Nathanial Lyon was rapidly trying to position his three brigades where they could take advantage of the terrain, on Bloody Hill, to launch an assault against McCullough and Price.  It became a race to see which side could launch an attack first.  By 6:30 a.m., Lyon had organized his forces at the top of the hill.  On the far left was the 1st Iowa Infantry, on their right were six companies of the 1st Kansas Infantry, Totten’s six gun battery of the 2d U.S. Artillery, the remaining four companies of the 1st Kansas, 1st Missouri Infantry and the 2d Missouri Infantry Battalion.  Du Bois had his four gun battery positioned to the rear of Totten and the 2d Kansas Infantry was placed in reserve.  Combined, Lyon had roughly 2,800 troops in place.  Facing them were the infantry of Sterling Price’s Missouri State Guard and Cawthorn’s disorganized mob of militia cavalry.  Price was valiantly attempted to get his lines organized.

Lyon would strike first.  Sending six companies of the 1st Kansas and the entire 1st Missouri Infantry surging down the hill, he was committing less than half of his force to attack the Missouri State Guard, which numbered nearly 5,000 troops.(xiii)  It is not known why Lyon decided to send such a small force, but is can be assumed that he wanted to keep a healthy reserve as he knew the attacking force would be enfiladed by the Pulaski Battery near the Winn house.  The 1st Missouri would push ahead first, followed on their left by the six companies of Kansas infantry. Because the Kansans had to maneuver around Totten’s guns, they were slow in organizing their ranks to push down the hill.  As they marched towards The Federal position on Bloody HillPrice’s battle line, 800 yards distant, they would move on opposite sides of a wooded ravine, separate by perhaps sixty yards.  Confederates, after hearing Union officers giving orders, and soldiers coming through the ravine, prepared to meet them.  With only a portion of his line complete, and not enough ammunition for all his units, Price was content to wait for their arrival.  They did not have to wait long, as the Federal soldiers began to appear between the widely spaced trees, and above the scrub brush that dotted the hillside.  Scattered fire from the Missouri State Guard, many of which had not been issued proper muskets (some were using hunting guns), began to play on the Federals.  Causing little damage, they pushed on.  Once they were in range, however, the entire line of the Missouri State Guard opened fire on them.  The musket fire was hot, and heavy.  It was estimated that the distance between the opposing lines was between 40–100 yards.  Because the woodlot had separated the two Federal regiments, each fought separately.  After a short time, Lyon ordered the rest of the 1st Kansas into the fight.  White acidic smoke began to cover the battlefield.  The commanders in Price’s command ordered their troops to conserve their ammunition, “…save your ammunition; don’t fire without taking steady aim.”(xiv)  Over the next thirty minutes the battle would rage.  At the crest of Bloody Hill, with Totten’s Battery now having no infantry support after the departure of the Kansans, Lyon ordered up US Captain Frederick Steele’s regular army battalion.  This allowed the Federal artillery batteries to keep up a withering fire.  One Rebel soldiers last words were, “Scatter, boys, you are making a target for their cannon.”(xv)  At that second, incoming artillery rounds be-headed two Confederate soldiers.

With the artillery duel between the Federal artillery, and the Pulaski Battery, Lyon’s forces at the top of Bloody Hill were unable to move.  By this time, Henry Guibor’s Missouri Light Artillery (Confederate) had moved to a position on the left flank of the Missouri State Guard.  Once in battery, these guns proved very deadly for the 1st Missouri Infantry on the right Guibor's Missouri State Guard battery positionFederal attacking flank.  With additional State Guard troops moving to the Federal right, US Lieutenant Colonel George Andrews’ 1st Missouri Infantry’s position was untenable.  They had been flanked.  They began a fighting retreat back towards the main line at the top of the hill.  Stopping to face the new threat, the 1st Missouri was positioned with its right flank refused, awaiting the Rebel infantry attack.  The portion of the line facing Guibor’s Battery continued to take artillery hits – fortunately many of the artillery shells did not explode.  Battlefield accounts during this first Confederate counterattack were sketchy.  However, it is believed that some of the artillery shells, the 1st Missouri were taking, were coming from Backof’s Federal battery, located in Sharp’s field.

Further to the Federal left, the remainder of the Missouri State Guard began to push towards the 1st Kansas.  The fire was intense.  Sergeant George W. Hutt, of Atchison’s All Hazard Company (1st Kansas), described the fire, “…a perfect hurricane of bullets.  For a few minutes the struggle was terrible and the anxiety was exhibited on all faces.”(xvi)  The brave Kansans would remain in their musketry raked position until the 1st Missouri began to retreat.  Soon they would follow.  Due to the disjointed, uncoordinated Federal attack, by 7:30 a.m. the Federals were back in their original position.  Confusion reined, as the 1st Kansas was now facing MSG Colonel Richard Weightman’s State Guard brigade – many of which wore similar blue uniforms as the Kansans.  Numbering over 1,000 men, Weightman’s Brigade seriously jeopardized the Federal position.  Lyon ordering the 2d Kansas from its reserve position, to support the main line, ordered the 1st Kansas to fix bayonets and charge Weightman’s Brigade.  Fewer than 200 soldiers actually pushed back down Bloody Hill, but the unexpected ferocity of the Kansans sent the State Guard troops reeling several hundred yards down the hill.  The commander of the 1st Kansas, US Colonel George Deitzler was wounded in the attack and would be carried off the field.  This left the lone Kansans separated from the rest of the Federal army, with no commander.  Lyon ordered them back to the main line, with the exception being the Leavenworth Light Infantry, commanded by Captain Powell Clayton, which did not hear Lyon’s recall order.  In what would be one of the most unusual events of the entire battle, Clayton’s men would dress ranks and continue their push down Bloody Hill.  Running into the 5th Missouri (MSG), of Weightman’s Brigade, they believed they were part of Sigel’s attacking column having pushed through the Confederate line.  They were wearing gray uniforms similar to Sigel’s men.  When the colonel of the 5th Missouri asked Clayton which direction the enemy was, Clayton pointed towards the southwest, at which point the two opposing forces marched off together!  Before they had marched thirty yards, Clayton realized he was amongst the enemy.  Ordering his men to separate, by a right oblique move, they began to separate from the Rebels.  The adjutant of the 5th Missouri (MSG), Captain Michael W. Buster, became suspicious and ordered the men to halt, and identify themselves.  Clayton halted his men, and grabbed Buster from his horse, pointing his pistol at his chest and commanding, “Now, sir, God damn you, order your men not to fire on us, or you are a dead man.”  Buster, turning to his commander, he said, “There sir, is my colonel.”  By then the 5th Missouri (MSG) had wheeled their position and faced Clayton’s Kansans.  The Missourians let loose a volley, and Buster was shot at close range by Clayton, but was not seriously injured.  Turning quickly to his men, Clayton ordered his men to, “…run for their lives.”(xvii)

By this time, the 2d Kansas had marched over the crest of Bloody Hill.  Taking position on the left flank of the 1st Missouri, they fired a nasty volley into the Missouri State Guard.  Equipped with old flintlock rifles, that had been converted to percussion, they fired buck-and-ball – essentially a shotgun type of charge.  The charge of the 2d Kansas, in conjunction with the 1st Missouri, took all the energy out of the attacking Missouri State Guards.  Retreating down the hill, Price would once again set to work organizing his line.

Around 7:15 a.m., CSA General Ben McCullough set off to appraise the situation of Sigel’s attack on the rear of his army.  Heading south on the Wire Road, he was able to assess the damage Sigel had done to his cavalry, but he was also able to see that Sigel’s troop placements were defective.  Additionally, Backof’s Battery was placed on a rise near the Sharp home, directing their fire on the slope of Bloody Hill.  Viewing the terrain surround the battery, McCullough quickly realized that Sigel was vulnerable.  Sigel, meanwhile, had started to reposition some of his artillery so the Wire Road was covered.  He could also view enemy movement on his left, that he believed pointed to a rout of the Missouri State Guard by Lyon.  Sigel was confident of success.  He never realized how perilous his position was, separated from Lyon’s forces, with a much larger enemy force between them.  He had a cavalry force, but he was not using it to scout the position between himself and Lyon.  McCullough was already planning his counterattack against Sigel.  On his way back north, towards his headquarters at the Winn house, McCullough came upon two companies of Louisiana troops – the Pelican Rifles and the Iberville Grays.  Urging them back across Wilson’s Creek, McCullough inspired the boys, “Come, my brave lads, I have a battery for you to charge and the day is ours.”  These were good soldiers and they followed his lead.(xviii)  Leading the soldiers across Skegg’s Branch, McCullough’s force of roughly 100 men pushed away Sigel’s skirmishers.  Sigel meanwhile had been given faulty intelligence that a dust cloud, coming down the road, was from Lyon’s troops and encouraged him to display the U.S. flag to identify themselves.  With all this going on, McCullough was able to organize the two companies at Skegg’s Branch, and additional reinforcements that were brought by Colonel McIntosh, and prepare them to charge Backof’s Battery.  Sigel, concerned about firing into his troops, urged his troops to not fire into them as they were approaching down the road.  With the 3d and 5th Missouri Infantry (US) advising their troops not to fire into the soldiers on the Wire Road, Sigel dispatch Private Charles Todt to go meet the friendly soldiers.  Approaching McCullough’s troops, young Todt quickly realized they were not friendly troops.  Raising One of Backof's gunshis musket to McCullough, he was quickly killed.  At this, McCullough turned to Captain Vigilini and said, “Captain, take your men up and give them hell.”(xix)  The Louisianans and troops from the Missouri State Guard charged out of Skegg’s Branch.  They were greeted with intense artillery fire, but besides Backof’s Battery, there were only 250 men of the 3d Missouri to support a line several hundred yards wide.  The Confederate forces quickly overwhelmed Sigel’s scant force, with nearly 100 of the Federals becoming casualties.  The Yankee troops were caught by surprise and were not ready.  They were expecting these troops to be from Lyon’s force, and the gray uniforms caused them to believe they were the 1st Iowa – also wearing gray.  The situation for Sigel turned hopeless when Rosser’s Missouri State Guard appeared on the ridge on their left, launching into their flank.  Sigel tried valiantly to organize his troops, but many still believed they were facing a friendly regiment.  Soon, pandemonium broke out and Sigel’s brigade, roughly three times the size of their attackers, melted away with one thing on their mind – escape.  McCullough now controlled his southern line again, and the area around the Sharp house was free of Federals.  Still facing a crisis on Bloody Hill, McCullough did not order a pursuit of Sigel.  Sigel’s brigade did not stop their retreat until they reached Springfield.

On Bloody Hill, the lull in the fighting lasted until about 9:00 a.m.  Lyon made very few adjustments of his line during this time.  Plummer’s Regulars arrived to reinforce the lines - minus Plummer as he had been carried from the field, wounded.  Lyon now had around 3,500 men to face the entire Confederate Western Army and Price’s Missouri State Guard.  With renewed artillery fire from the Confederates, many of the Federal troops were prone, Samuel Sturgis - US Major at Wilson's Creekon the ground.  It was not long before Lyon’s forces saw the Confederate infantry approaching, and opened fire.  A desperate battle would continue for nearly an hour.  US Major Samuel Sturgis, commanding Lyon’s First Brigade would later state that the fighting became “almost inconceivably fierce along the entire line.”(xx)  With the Rebel forces pushing through a ravine, they appeared within thirty yards of Totten’s Battery, which began to suffer casualties.  They would continue a terrific cannonade into the approach Confederates, buying additional time.  By this time, Lyon was directing his troops on foot.  He would suffer two minor wounds, one to his leg and another grazing shot to his head.  He was said to have blood matted in his beard as he continued to direct is troops.  In the center of the Union line, the First Iowa became entangled with Kansans pulling back from the heavy fire.  With Lyon, now on horseback, commanding from behind the 1st Iowa, several Confederate horsemen appeared in front of their infantry.  Lyon believing it was Sterling Price, told his escort, “to draw pistols and follow.”(xxi)  Fortunately, his escorts talked him out of putting himself in such a vulnerable position.  With Sturgis organizing the 1st Iowa, Lyon brought the 2d Kansas out of line to charge the enemy stating, “Come my brave boys, I will lead you forward.”  As they were preparing to charge, a volley of Rebel musketry erupted from the brush.  Lyon would be shot through both lungs, and his heart.  Falling from his horse, his personal aide, Albert Lehmann would catch him.  Lyon’s last words were, “Lehmann, I am going.”  Lyon would be the first Federal general officer to die in the Civil War.(xxii)  He would be taken to the Ray house where he would be placed on a bed in their front bedroom.

The fighting would continue for some time, as the Federal troops reorganized their ranks.  The Confederates would finally pull back, allowing Lyon’s troops to recover their dead and wounded.  The Confederates would suffer a significant casualty when Colonel Richard Weightman fell mortally wounded.

Wilson's Creek Battlefield Map from the CWPTAround 8:45 a.m., after nearly four hours of fighting at Bloody Hill, Sterling Price sent a staffer to find McCullough.  Finding him near the Sharp farm, he advised the general that the Missouri State Guard was extremely pressed on Bloody Hill, and that the line may collapse without immediate reinforcements.  McCullough immediately sent orders for all available units to move to the hill.  This included CSA Brigadier General Bart Pearce’s brigade of Arkansas State Troops and Samuel Hyman’s battalion of the 3d Louisiana Infantry.  It was McCullough’s desire to put all the available manpower on the last remaining threat – Lyon’s three brigades (now commanded by Major Samuel Sturgis) on the Bloody Hill.  “Old Ben” (McCullough) gave a rousing speech to his forces, “You have beaten the enemy’s right and left wings, only their centre is left, and with all of our forces concentrated upon that we will soon make short work of it.”(xxiii)  As Piston and Hatcher explain in their book, “Wilson’s Creek,” the work turned out to be anything but short.  With orders reaching Colonel Elkanah Greer, to use all his available forces, from the 2d South Kansas-Texas Cavalry, to turn the enemy’s right flank, he immediately set out to work.  Only having a portion of his command left, as several companies were separated after Sigel’s initial attack at the Sharp Farm, he trotted north with his battalion.  On his way towards his mission, he would meet Colonel DeRosey Carroll and his 1st Arkansas Cavalry, who would join him for the flank movement.  Reaching their staging point, and dressing his lines, Greer yelled to his command, “Draw your pistols, men, and charge!”  One of his cavaliers, Bugler A.B. Blocker recalled the charge, “With a yell, we went toward the line of blue, like a wind….On we went-pouring lead into the blue line that was standing there 50 yards in front of us, with fixed bayonets, prepared to receive the cavalry.  The next moment that blue line was a mass of running, stampeding soldiers trying to get out of the way of that mass of horses and men that were bearing down on them.”(xxiv)  While some men probably did retreat, the Federals made a good show of themselves, eventually turning away the cavalry charge.  With heavy musketry, and artillery fire from Totten’s Battery, Greer was fortunate to only suffer 24 casualties.

At the same time as Greer’s cavaliers were charging the Federal flank, Price pushed off with his Missouri State Guard.  Leading from the front, wearing a white duster and white hat, he was said to look more like a farmer than a commanding general.  This second attack, like the first, suffered from moving over uneven terrain, with little ability to attack from a unified front.  Price would have several bullets pass through his clothing before he was finally grazed by a bullet in his side.  Price commented to an officer near him, “That isn’t fair; if I were as slim as Lyon that fellow would have missed me entirely.”  Fortunately for Price, although painful, the wound did not require immediate medical care and he stayed on the field.  As before, the State Guard suffered from a shortage of ammunition, forcing them to move closely to Sturgis’ command before discharging their weapons, the result of which has been characterized as a series of jerky forward movements.(xxv)  Once again, Price’s largely “green” force was pushed back down the hill. 

Sterling Price at Wilson's Creek While Sturgis dealt with his alignment, Price was working to coordinate the largest attack of the day.  McCullough had arrived with the reunited 3d Louisiana commanded by Louis Hebert and additional reinforcements came from near Ray’s cornfield: three companies of the 5th Arkansas Infantry, and Colonel John R. Gratiot’s 3d Arkansas.   Price had significantly more firepower to make a final charge.  Arrayed from left to right were the 3d Arkansas, seven companies of the 5th Arkansas, two regiments of the Missouri State Guard, 1st Arkansas Mounted Rifles, Guibor’s Battery, another Missouri State Guard regiment, the 3d Missouri (MSG), the 5th Missouri (MSG), remnants of Cawthorn’s Cavalry and one one additional Missouri State Guard regiment holding the right flank.  Opening with artillery fire, from Guibor’s Battery, the 3d Arkansas started forward.  Quickly, they not only ran into fire from the front, but enfilade musketry from their left and Totten’s Battery fire from their right.  The men were forced to a prone position to keep from being annihilated.  They would suffer 110 casualties in just a few minutes time.  At approximate 10:30 a.m., the entire reinforced Confederate line started forward.  Approaching Sturgis’ Federal line, the brunt of the attack would be received in the center of the Yankee line.  With many of the Federals laying on the ground, they were forced to fire from a prone position.  The tall prairie grass, and clouds of white smoke covered the battlefield making it hard for them to see their targets.  With artillery support from the Sharp farm, McCullough and Price’s soldiers pushed forward.  The musket fire Marker at the site of Nathial Lyon's deathbecame so intense that one Kansan said, “(it sounded like) hundreds of bunches of firecrackers going off.”  After about 45 minutes, Price once again called for his troops to retreat, and reform.  On the Federal side, the 2d Kansas had run out of ammunition, and moved to the rear.  With the Confederates retreating, Sturgis determined the battle was lost and started to pull troops from his right flank with Du Bois’ Battery and the 2d Missouri following the 2d Kansas to the rear.  Seeing the Federal right flank uncovered, Hebert pushed his 3d Louisiana into action.  They would be quickly overcome by the quickly dispatched Regular Battalion of Captain Frederick Steele.  Sturgis then ordered Totten to limber his artillery and retreat off Bloody Hill, with the 1st Iowa, 1st Kansas, Home Guards and the 13th Illinois quickly following.  Totten’s battery horses would be killed, in their retreat.  Quickly recognizing that the guns may be lost, Corporal Lorenzo Immell quickly went and cut the traces from the dead horses.  With help from Private Nicholas Bouquet, of the Burlington Rifles, a horse was found to pull the caisson to the rear.  Immell would receive a painful wound in his shin, from a spent minie ball.  Both soldiers would receive the Congressional Medal of Honor for their actions to save the caisson, removing any ammunition that could be used in their stranded guns, against them.  Steele’s Regulars were acting as the rear guard, on Bloody Hill.  Within a few minutes, Confederates were seen pushing towards their exposed position.  Racing to the rear, Steele returned with several companies from the 1st Iowa, 1st Missouri and 1st Kansas.  Forming his small line, Steele ordered them to fire into the approaching enemy.  The blistering fire, from this small group of soldiers, sent the Rebels in a mad dash back down the hill.  Steele wasted no time ordering his small defensive unit to the rear once his front was clear of attackers.  The retreating Federals reached Springfield around 5:00 p.m. – nearly 24 hours after they left.  After finding Bloody Hill had been abandoned, the Confederates did not pursue.  The Western Army was “fought out.”  Years after the battle, CSA Brigadier General Bart Pearce summed up the feelings of the Confederates, “We watched the retreating enemy through our field-glasses and were glad to see him go.”(xxvi)

Several factors contributed to the Federal defeat at Wilson’s Creek.

  1. Lyon’s forces were significantly smaller than those he attacked.  Military protocol usually demands that an attacking force should be three times the strength of the enemy.  In this case, the attacking force was 1/3 the strength of their foe.
  2. The adoption of Franz Sigel’s flanking plan was a poor decision by Lyon.  Even with his commanders (with the exception of Sigel) not supporting this plan, Lyon adopted it.  This inevitably discouraged his commanders as Lyon went against the will of his immediate lieutenants making the council of war a mockery.
  3. Even if perfectly coordinated, from a tactical sense, Sigel’s small attacking force offered little chance of military success.  Unfortunately, due to defective placement of his forces, Sigel’s slim chance became impossible – leading to the rout of his command and an early retreat to Springfield.

This author does not agree with other scholars with regards to the impact of Lyon’s death.  Lyon at times was overwhelmed trying to command a disintegrating position.  He could not manage the actions of the south side of the battlefield.  Once he was killed, Major Samuel Sturgis performed very well in overall command (Sturgis would reach the rank of brigadier general in the regular army).  He had a better tactical sense of his surroundings and responded well to all exigencies that occurred – especially during the most dangerous portion of the fight – the withdrawal.

Campaign: Wilson’s Creek

Outcome: Confederate victory

Troop Strengths
Union: 5,400
Confederate: 12,000 (approximate)

Casualties (estimated):
Union: 1,235 (killed, wounded or missing/captured)
Confederate: 1,095 (killed, wounded or missing/captured)

Battle Aftermath:
The Battle of Wilson’s Creek was a significant defeat for the United States.  Still reeling from the Federal debacle at Bull Run, three weeks earlier, the country was mortified over the additional loss of life.  With the United States having no control in southwest Missouri, the Missouri State Guard, commanded by Sterling Price, would continue to raid Federal outposts, winning a stunning victory at Lexington, Missouri in a battle fought from September 13–20, 1861.  Additionally, with little Federal presence outside St. Louis, guerilla raiders became as much of a problem as the Missouri State Guard.  While the guerilla warfare would continue through the Civil War, in February 1862, US Major General Samuel Curtis would fight McCullough and Price at Pea Ridge, Arkansas.  The battle, also called Elk Horn Tavern, would be a complete Federal success, routing the forces commanded by CSA Major General Earl Van Dorn.  Brigadier General Ben McCullough would be killed in the fighting.  This would end the Confederate presence in Missouri, until 1864, when Sterling Price once again raided the state.

(i) Work, David, Lincoln’s Political Generals, published by the University of Illinois Press in 2009, Pg. 7.
(ii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 36.
(iii) Work, David, Lincoln’s Political Generals, published by the University of Illinois Press in 2009, Pg. 21.
(iv) Work, David, Lincoln’s Political Generals, published by the University of Illinois Press in 2009, Pg. 37.
(v) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 144.
(vi) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 147.
(vii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 199.
(viii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 202.
(ix) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 203.
(x) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 215.
(xi) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 216.
(xii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 218.
(xiii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 337.
(xiv) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 235.
(xv) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 236.
(xvi) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 242.
(xvii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 244.
(xviii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 251.
(xix) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 253.
(xx) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 263.
(xxi) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 265.
(xxii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 268.
(xxiii) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 270.
(xxiv) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 271.
(xxv) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 273.
(xxvi) Piston, William Garrett and Hatcher, Richard W. III, Wilson’s Creek: The Second Battle of the Civil War and the Men Who Fought It, published by The University of North Carolina Press in 2000, Pg. 286.

VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Please rate this article
Rating: 5.0/5 (3 votes cast)
VN:F [1.8.3_1051]
Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)

Powered by WordPress. Theme: TheBuckmaker. Schulden, Nebenjob von zu Hause